That was based on a small amount of mostly short kicks and it's not even true anymore after his recent misses. His % beyond 40 is objectively bad by any measure.
I realize once we get in our mind a player is bad, no facts or stats are going to change it. But for the rest of us here are the facts.
Yes, as of now he’s only in 4th place all time.
Here’s a bit of perspective on that. He’s .6 of a percentage point out of second (77.9 to 77.3).
The small amount you refer to are during his freshman and sophomore years. Short kicks? Literally half of his attempts this year were 40+ yards. Last year 12 of his 26 attempts were 40+. So roughly half of all attempts were 40+. That’s not a small amount.
Our career leader in fg % is Campbell (78.3)…based on a single season as a senior. I’m sure those extra years of growth and experience had no affect. Oh, and he was 3 of 8 from 40+ and his longest fg was 49 yards. There’s a small amount.
Second is Walls at 77.9%. That percentage is based on 4 years.
Third is McGrath at 77.8%. His numbers were based on only his jr and sr years. He was 8 of 14 at 40+ with 1 over 50, that was 51 yards.
Gilbert is next at 77.3%, again based on his fr and soph years. He is 13 of 21 at 40+ with almost half of those 50+ and he’s hit 5 at 50+.
Gilbert compares very favorably to our best, and no he’s not bad by any measure beyond 40. (I don’t even know what that means since there’s only one measure that counts). And he’s only a sophomore.
No kicker is perfect, (except maybe that dude from Oklahoma.) They’ve all missed big kicks or what some would say cost us a game.