For those that are interested, here is the prompt I used. ChatGPT 5.1 nailed the retrieval, but couldn't figure out the format I needed until I asked for it as
@Freak suggested. Claude, Gemini, and Grok, all in their most current versions, failed in one way or another. Not unusual. Seems common for one or the other to be better at something, but with no pattern I've been able to discern.
The prompt (with my typo uncorrected!) (and, the forum converted the url for this thread into a linked title.):
From the predictions forum members have made in the thread at the following link, create me a table if predictions with user name, Lady Vols score, Coppin State's score, and the total points predicted.
Game Thread: #15 Lady Volunteers 4-1 vs Coppin St. 1-4 Sunday, 11-23-25 @ 2:00PM EST Knoxville, TN. SECN+