Time for a Defensive Upgrade: Why Tennessee Should Hire Ron Roberts as Defensive Coordinator

#34
#34
I can't argue with any of that. We looked scared Saturday. By the end of the first quarter, I think some of the players were asking if they could get back on the bus. I've never seen a FL team look scared ever.
 
#35
#35
Eastknox865 said:
I don't need excuses. The defense played well enough to win the game even with the miscues. The offense lost the game. And this same coordinator led us to the playoffs last year
Click to expand...

James Pierce and Jermod McCoy led UT to the playoffs. Tim Banks didn't coach or recruit either of them. Tim Banks coaches and recruits the weakest position group on the field. He is the worst DC Tennessee has had since Sunseri unless we are supposed to magically forget the first two years he was here and this season. So he fields a competent defense two out of every five seasons? Awesome, so we should swing upwards again in 2027, good to know!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Native Orange
#41
#41
Lane Train 4 said:
With the Florida Gators firing head coach Billy Napier on October 19, 2025, after a 3-4 start and a 22-23 overall record, a prime opportunity has emerged for the Tennessee Volunteers. The Gators' coaching shakeup puts Ron Roberts, their defensive coordinator, on the market, and his proven track record could transform Tennessee's defense. With the Vols' defense cratering in 2025 under current coordinator Tim Banks, hiring Roberts could be the spark to vault Tennessee back into playoff contention. Here's why athletic director Danny White should act swiftly to bring Roberts to Knoxville, especially when the defensive line and pass rush coaches are already laying a strong foundation for success.

Roberts' Proven Excellence: A Defensive Mastermind

Ron Roberts brings 31 years of coaching experience, with success at every stop. From leading Delta State as head coach to guiding Southeastern Louisiana to consecutive FCS playoffs with a 42-29 record, Roberts has consistently delivered. His Power Five credentials stand out. At Baylor in 2021, he crafted the Big 12's top scoring defense, powering a 12-win season, a conference championship, and a Sugar Bowl victory with a league-leading 19 interceptions. At Auburn in 2023, he turned a transitioning defense into a unit ranked 45th nationally in yards allowed and 41st in points. Even at Florida, despite the team's struggles, Roberts instilled discipline and structure, mentoring standout players and showing flashes of defensive brilliance. His signature 4-2-5 nickel defense blends speed, versatility, and aggression, built for the SEC's high-powered offenses. Roberts adapts schemes to his players, using man coverage and zone blitzes to disrupt quarterbacks. Baylor's Dave Aranda called him a mentor whose principles shaped championship defenses. Tennessee needs that caliber of leadership.

Tennessee's Defense Needs a Shakeup: Banks Is Falling Short

Tennessee's defense under Tim Banks has cratered in 2025, a far cry from its elite 2024 performance where the Vols ranked No. 6 nationally and allowed just 16.1 points per game. This season, they're allowing 32.7 points per game (107th nationally), 420 yards per game (98th), and opponents are converting 42.7% of third downs (93rd). This collapse, with chunk plays, poor adjustments, and second-half breakdowns, exposes schematic flaws. A tough outing against Alabama highlighted these issues, fueling doubts about Banks' ability to sustain dominance. While Banks deserves credit for past successes, the 2025 nosedive, marked by modest sack totals despite talent like edge rusher Joshua Josephs (4 sacks), screams for change.

The key point: Tennessee's remaining defensive strengths in 2025 come largely from Rodney Garner, the legendary defensive line coach, and Levorn "Chop" Harbin, the dynamic outside linebackers and pass rush coach. Garner has molded a physical, disruptive front, with players like James Pearce Jr. and Tyre West anchoring the line. Harbin, promoted in February 2025 after serving as a senior defensive analyst, has brought elite edge expertise, elevating Josephs (90.8 PFF pass-rush grade) and others to generate consistent pressure. These coaches are the engine behind Tennessee's defensive line success, masking some of Banks' schematic predictability. Pairing their foundation with Roberts' innovative play-calling could unlock a truly elite defense.

A Seamless Fit: Roberts Elevates Heupel's Vision

Josh Heupel's high-octane offense thrives when the defense creates turnovers and short fields, exactly what Roberts' aggressive schemes deliver. His approach would complement Tennessee's scoring machine, turning stops into points. Picture Roberts deploying his nickel sets against spread offenses like Georgia or Ole Miss, using creative blitzes to rattle quarterbacks. With Garner and Harbin already producing a dominant front seven, Roberts could amplify their impact, while corners like Jermod McCoy and Jalen McMurray thrive in his adaptable coverages.

Roberts' SEC experience at Auburn and Florida equips him for the conference's intensity, recruiting battles, and expectations. Some Florida fans even floated him as a head coaching candidate post-Napier, praising his leadership amid adversity. Tennessee's passionate fanbase and top-tier resources give Roberts the platform to build a top-10 defense by 2026.

Addressing Concerns: A Low-Risk, High-Reward Move

Hiring Roberts carries minor risks. He's moved frequently in recent years, and some Auburn chatter noted personality concerns. But his results, championships, elite rankings, and player development far outweigh any drawbacks. With Garner and Harbin driving the defensive line's success, Roberts is the missing piece to tie it all together, replacing Banks' proven but now-failing schemes with dynamic, aggressive play-calling.

Act Now: Roberts Can Restore Tennessee's SEC Dominance

The SEC demands excellence, and Tennessee's defense can't rely solely on Garner and Harbin's brilliance to carry it through this collapse. With Napier gone, Ron Roberts is available, a battle-tested, innovative coordinator ready to elevate Tennessee's talent. Danny White, this is the moment. Hire Roberts now, let him build on the foundation laid by Garner and Harbin, and watch the Vols surge back to SEC glory. The future starts today.
Click to expand...
I would be absolutely fine with it. But it’s a pipe dream and won’t happen.
 
#43
#43
landscapingvol said:
James Pierce and Jermod McCoy led UT to the playoffs. Tim Banks didn't coach or recruit either of them. Tim Banks coaches and recruits the weakest position group on the field. He is the worst DC Tennessee has had since Sunseri unless we are supposed to magically forget the first two years he was here and this season. So he fields a competent defense two out of every five seasons? Awesome, so we should swing upwards again in 2027, good to know!
Click to expand...
So Banks wasn’t the DC last year?
 
#45
#45
Eastknox865 said:
The problem with our defense isn't the DC it's the players not executing, some players not talented enough to execute, and some players being injured. And on top of that when the defense gets turneovers or stops the offense isn't getting points off of them. Often going 3 and out in less than a minute putting a tired defense right back on the field. Pay attention to the entire product
Click to expand...
Much of what you mention is true except for your first sentence. Does UL have more talent as they attack at all 3 levels. No. If you watched the Miami game you’d notice an attacking team on their toes instead of confused team on their heels. Is it Telanders fault we don’t stop a 3rd and 2 as he’s 15 yards downfield in deep zone guarding grass? Also no. As you mentioned, pay attention to everything, not just what you want to see.
 
#47
#47
Skooter said:
Much of what you mention is true except for your first sentence. Does UL have more talent as they attack at all 3 levels. No. If you watched the Miami game you’d notice an attacking team on their toes instead of confused team on their heels. Is it Telanders fault we don’t stop a 3rd and 2 as he’s 15 yards downfield in deep zone guarding grass? Also no. As you mentioned, pay attention to everything, not just what you want to see.
Click to expand...
When a play is called we don't know each players responsibility so we have no clue rather he is out of position because of his decision or the play call. So stop
 
#48
#48
landscapingvol said:
James Pierce and Jermod McCoy led UT to the playoffs. Tim Banks didn't coach or recruit either of them. Tim Banks coaches and recruits the weakest position group on the field. He is the worst DC Tennessee has had since Sunseri unless we are supposed to magically forget the first two years he was here and this season. So he fields a competent defense two out of every five seasons? Awesome, so we should swing upwards again in 2027, good to know!
Click to expand...
If the Dc gets the blame for failure he also gets the credit for success.
 
#50
#50
Eastknox865 said:
The problem with our defense isn't the DC it's the players not executing, some players not talented enough to execute, and some players being injured. And on top of that when the defense gets turneovers or stops the offense isn't getting points off of them. Often going 3 and out in less than a minute putting a tired defense right back on the field. Pay attention to the entire product
Click to expand...
Whose job it is to ensure the players execute? Whose job is it to recruit the type of players we need? The fact we’re getting this level of play on defense in year 5 is inexcusable. I was a big Banks defender all the way up until this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Native Orange and Tennessee Cowboy
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top