The Problems with Trans-ideology

#8,177
#8,177
Vol8188 said:
Odd because you now have multiple examples and they’re somehow not “elite” by your insane standard.

Winning the national championship and setting world records just isn’t enough for you
Click to expand...
Still not one. Zero records, zero pros who were any good, nothing a trans woman has done that hasn't been bettered by dozens of biological women. Unless you have an example
 
#8,178
#8,178
C-south said:
This is just another absolutely retarded stance. Maybe she wasn’t and that’s ok, they were actually women that beat her. But it doesn’t matter. Even the weakest, simpest, most mentally unstable tranny still should t be competing with women.
Click to expand...

She was banned by the rules
 
  • Like
Reactions: C-south
#8,179
#8,179
NashVol11 said:
Still not one. Zero records, zero pros who were any good, nothing a trans woman has done that hasn't been bettered by dozens of biological women. Unless you have an example
Click to expand...

“That hasn’t been bettered”…wait now, you told me earlier they didn’t have to be the greatest?

You have a D1 National championship and a world record holder you’ve been made aware of.

Why are you moving the goalposts?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82_VOL_83
#8,180
#8,180
He’s selecting from an insanely limited pool of people, that becomes even smaller due to severe mental illness, even smaller due to rules prohibiting them from competing, and then attempting to make an insane claim that even my 6 year old understands is wrong.

Drunk, high, TBI. Only logical options at this point
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82_VOL_83
#8,181
#8,181
Vol8188 said:
“That hasn’t been bettered”…wait now, you told me earlier they didn’t have to be the greatest?

You have a D1 National championship and a world record holder you’ve been made aware of.

Why are you moving the goalposts?
Click to expand...
Bettered by whom? Dozens of women? At least complete the sentence instead of lying about it. That cyclist does not hold a "world record" and Thomas doesn't hold any record
 
#8,182
#8,182
NashVol11 said:
Bettered by whom? Dozens of women? At least complete the sentence instead of lying about it. That cyclist does not hold a "world record" and Thomas doesn't hold any record
Click to expand...

She does (or did, idk if it’s still valid) hold a world record and Lia Thomas was the D1 national champion.

You’ve moving the goal posts hard here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82_VOL_83
#8,183
#8,183
Vol8188 said:
He’s selecting from an insanely limited pool of people, that becomes even smaller due to severe mental illness, even smaller due to rules prohibiting them from competing, and then attempting to make an insane claim that even my 6 year old understands is wrong.
Click to expand...
Seems like the existing rules were working, then. No wonder you had to start deflecting and lying when I said that
 
#8,186
#8,186
Vol8188 said:
“That hasn’t been bettered”…wait now, you told me earlier they didn’t have to be the greatest?

You have a D1 National championship and a world record holder you’ve been made aware of.

Why are you moving the goalposts?
Click to expand...

You moved the goalposts. Nobody cares if they are competitive. There’s no place in women’s sports for dudes regardless of their mental state or feelings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82_VOL_83
#8,187
#8,187
NashVol11 said:
Well, if the "massive unfair advantage" never shows itself once, ever, in any sport, across several decades, then this seems to be a "solution" without a problem and based on fearmongering rather than reality. It seems like the existing limitations were working, no?
Click to expand...
8188 will never respond to this substantively, only with deflections lol
 
#8,188
#8,188
Like, we needed legislation because a trans woman set the women's cycling record for 200m sprinters who are age 35-44, likely nowhere close to the actual women's record and not even in the U.S.? So much for small government
 
#8,189
#8,189
NashVol11 said:
8188 will never respond to this substantively, only with deflections lol
Click to expand...

No one is deflecting we’ve provided examples and you’ve discounted them.

I provided you a very simply an obvious example with height. A man competing in women’s sports would go from 50th percentile to top 5 percentile instantly.

Is that an advantage?
 
#8,190
#8,190
NashVol11 said:
Like, we needed legislation because a trans woman set the women's cycling record for 200m sprinters who are age 35-44, likely nowhere close to the actual women's record and not even in the U.S.? So much for small government
Click to expand...

“Not even in the US”-hey genius, it was the world record.
 
#8,191
#8,191
Vol8188 said:
No one is deflecting we’ve provided examples and you’ve discounted them.

I provided you a very simply an obvious example with height. A man competing in women’s sports would go from 50th percentile to top 5 percentile instantly.

Is that an advantage?
Click to expand...
Hypotheticals about men are, by definition, not examples lol
 
#8,192
#8,192
Vol8188 said:
“Not even in the US”-hey genius, it was the world record.
Click to expand...
For 200m women's sprinters age 35-44, get it right, but you missed the point anyway. That didn't even happen here and is based on rules from an international governing body and we needed U.S. federal government intervention? This is the small government I keep hearing about?
 
#8,193
#8,193
NashVol11 said:
For 200m women's sprinters age 35-44, get it right, but you missed the point anyway. That didn't even happen here and is based on rules from an international governing body and we needed U.S. federal government intervention? This is the small government I keep hearing about?
Click to expand...

This is like discounting a boxing championship because they weren’t a heavy weight. If you’re old enough for that division and you set the world record in that division, that’s insanely impressive
 
#8,195
#8,195
I pointed out that the existing rules seemed to have been working just fine and that no trans woman has been "dominating" any sport ever and look how quickly someone deflected again lol
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement

Back
Top