I don't think it's harsh. That's exactly how Milton played when he started for us last year. You can tell he has all the physical tools in the world but he never put it together during a game. The guys that cover the team say he still throws the prettiest ball in practice but we all know that Hooker is our starting QB for a reason. Milton isn't a gamer and Hooker is.
How about letting last season, be last season, then wait and hope this season's version of Milton is a better one? If you had a boss (or spouse) who utterly refused to ignore your efforts to be better. Who just as stubbornly refused to let go of the fact you made a mistake, or even did something stupid a year ago, and badmouthed you at every opportunity, how'd that work for you? If either the version of you or Milton repeated the same or worse mistakes of the past, it indicates a refusal or inability to learn. In which case, saying
"get out of here and don't come back" would be warranted. Until then, try sitting the glass of expired 8yrs ago Clamato-Brussel sprouts juice cocktail down, and drink a glass of fresh squeezed orange juice instead.
Not to be personal, it's just as a fan, I don't do or tolerate Vol-hate very well. I don't even dislike JG, who was stuck with a coach who couldn't coach, got the
heil knocked out of him over and over. Yet dragged his butt off the ground to get up and try again. He kept trying even after his own teammates walked off the field, leaving his aching body on the ground at game end, and was helped up by an opposing player who simply felt sorry for him. He was a terrible QB, but kept trying (JP should have stopped trotting him out there) when he had every reason not give a darn anymore. So, I say, "He was a Vol, I will not hate on him. I even have a measure of respect for him."