Both of the ones I've bought have been the PowerXL. I've had no trouble out of either one (frequent use).
This is the latest one we got, vg same as yours, but I got both of ours at Sam's.
View attachment 351566
The first one still works fine. I got the one above as a "backup," but we like the fact that this one doesn't have a separate removeable basket like the first one did. On this one, there's only one thing that has to align correctly. The old one had another smaller basket that had to attach to the larger basket (inside). There was a little button there to push to release the inner basket. That thing got fussy over time, but it still works. You just have to be careful. This one just has the little removeable grid. The only thing with this one is that (during cleaning, we think) one of the little rubber stops has gone missing.
Highly recommend the PowerXL.