Tony Romo. Everyone’s favorite Cowboys passer might have had the strongest case of the It Factor before Tebow arrived onto the scene. The
Fort Worth Star-Telegram speculated in an Andrew Sharp fever dream of a column that Romo had it
in January 2006, after Romo had sat on the bench for two years without throwing a single NFL pass! Before Romo’s first professional start, nine months later against the Panthers, Bill Parcells said Romo had “a personality [that exudes confidence].”
Romo started his career by playing brilliantly in winning five of his first six starts, a feat that turned Romo stories into a shooting gallery of projection. Teammate Bradie James said Romo had
“always had the swagger” and had “been the coolest dude around for a while.” Sean Payton, Romo’s former mentor in Dallas, noted that Romo was “confident” and “takes coaching well.” Even the most dissenting opinion, from Jennifer Floyd Engel of the
Star-Telegram, noted that Romo
“already has shown us that he possesses the ‘it’ factor” while fretting over whether Romo was elite. A
Minnesota Star-Tribune profile detailing Romo’s It Factor from the viewpoint of opposing players noted that
“there’s just something special about Tony,” a sentiment
shared by London Fletcher.
To top it all off,
a November 2007 article in
The Record of Bergen County, New Jersey, contrasted Romo’s It Factor and specialness with what was missing from Eli Manning, who lacked Romo’s “athleticism, instincts, and charisma.” This really deserves your undivided attention:
Born less than eight months apart, Romo is years ahead of Manning in the unscientific rankings of quarterbacks who might someday win a ring. Why? Start with the It factor, that impossible-to-define, easy-to-see something that Romo wears around as easily as the star on his helmet. The smile telling you he knows something you don’t. The swagger announcing that no season-crushing, Parcells-retiring fumble of a field goal snap will ever diminish the blind game-day faith he has in himself. Eli doesn’t have It, whatever It is.
Four months later, Eli and the Giants beat Romo and the Cowboys in Dallas before upsetting the Patriots in Super Bowl XLII. And that was it. People stopped writing articles suggesting that Romo had the It Factor virtually overnight. If I wrote an article today suggesting that Romo had it, I wouldn’t be able to check Twitter for a week. The world turned and left Tony Romo here.
A reporter actually
asked Romo what he thought about the It Factor. Romo, who often gives great answers to cliché-riddled questions, didn’t bite. “I don’t know what ‘it’ is,” Romo said. “I think you try to work hard, try to get better each week. I think I play the game with a little bit of passion. I think that’s the way I play. For some reason, people like me.” Oh, if only I could go back in time and warn that Tony Romo.