Okay, so let's play that out with slightly better granularity than you just provided.
Here are some various results and how they compare, fan attendance to regular season wins.
> 11-1 regular season (92%) == 93,917 fans in Neyland.
If we'd had 94k fans in Neyland yesterday (entire lower bowl packed, upper stands 3/4 full) I think CJP would've been ecstatic. And we fans would be ecstatic with an 11-1 finish.
> 9-3 regular season (75%) == 76,841 fans in Neyland.
So roughly 10k more than we had yesterday. Respectable, but not excellence. Just as we in VN.com were pointing out over the past two years that a 9-3 season is, while an improvement, not championship caliber. So, a step forward...but not the goal.
> 7-5 regular season (58%) == 59,765 fans in Neyland.
A 7-5 season sure beats the abysmal 4-8 we just lived through, but it's is nonetheless completely unacceptable for a storied program like ours. No one would be happy with it. Just as no one should be happy with less than 60,000 fans in Neyland. Ever. Even when it's a scrimmage.
...
This apples-and-oranges thought exercise isn't really useful for much, but it does highlight the difference between excellence, acceptableness, and mediocrity.
What CJP is looking for (and we demand that he does) is excellence. What we got yesterday, from both the players and the fans, was somewhere between acceptable and mediocre. And no one should be happy with either.
Think that's all he was saying. And I think he was right to make the observation.
Go Vols!