I don't have a recipe yet but the short answer to the ingredients is whatever is leftover. Some examples are....
Cabbage, squash, zucchini, onion, peppers (red, orange, green), jalapeño (to taste), cucumber, some add carrots. Not all of these are required. Turmeric, pickling spice, vinegar and sugar.
I just don't know and actually need to forget about it for a day or two. Logic tells me my grandma used any and everything, like you suggest, but I can't make myself believe she put cukes, zucchini and carrots in hers, although she grew all of them in large quantities.
Unless something changes, these are the veggies Im using.
Cabbage
Green tomatoes
Onion
Green bell
Red bell
Vinegar. I think red wine vinegar or Apple cider vinegar would work best, but I'm pretty sure she would have used white.
Sugar. Most recipes I've seen use brown, but again, I'm stumped. Brown sugar was/is more expensive, but you don't use as much. I know she used brown sugar in her baked beans because that's how my mom made them.
Pickling spice. Only one recipe I've seen, that seems to be the closest to what Im looking for, calls for it. I know for sure she and my mom used that stuff for other things, I'm really inclined to think I need this. It just makes sense, it has all the ingredients, and then some, that the others call for.....mustard seed, celery seed, turmeric etc. It also has crushed red pepper flakes. Almost certain that's why I could never get the heat right.:good!:
Also, all of these recipes make 8 quarts. I'm not making that many. I've got to break it down to two quarts and that will make a difference if I don't get it just right.
Blah, blah, blah. Just thinking out loud.