On a scale of 1 to 10 . . .

[cbrown]

If Dooley is a 1 and Saban is a 10, where would you rate Butch?

* I rate Saban a 10 not because he is flawless, but because he's the best in the business currently (and perhaps of all-time).

 

[Doberman]

5

Twice as good as Dooley, and half as good as Saban.

 

[Vato]

On speech 9, recruiting 8, coaching 1.5

 

[CladInOrange]

7

 

[hmhawk]

8

 

[photovol]

At his very best, Butch Jones is still a mid tier SEC coach with allot of coach speak phrases ......no more, no less

 

[vols 30]

6 maybe a 7

 

[Alto1]

5

Twice as good as Dooley, and half as good as Saban.

On speech 9, recruiting 8, coaching 1.5

Both post are hard to argue.........

 

[HuntlandVolinColo]

7

 

[JMSqb11]

How bout lets play what SEC coach is Butch better than....

Mason at Vandy
Stoops at Kentucky
Odom at Missouri
Smart at Georgia (could change next year)

Notice, there are only 4 coaches and they are in the East. Butch is in bottom tier in terms of coaching in the SEC.

 

[UTblood4life]

For the crap we were in, oh man bout 5.5-6, 7 had we gone to seccg, even the 7 is stretching it, :gone:

 

[TacomaJPP]

Is this scale log or linear?

 

[KBVol]

On speech 9, recruiting 8, coaching 1.5

Speech -8, recruiting 7, coaching 4-5.

 

[CladInOrange]

5

Twice as good as Dooley, and half as good as Saban.

Twice as good as Dooley would be a 2. Sorry had to do it.:birgits_giggle:

 

[VOL 4 Life 83]

SEC East = 6-7 (slightly above average based on win/loss record)
SEC West = 0 (never beat a west opponent, let that one sink in folks)

Overall SEC, I'll be gracious and say a 5. Is that good enough for UT? Guess so nowadays

 

[Doberman]

Twice as good as Dooley would be a 2. Sorry had to do it.:birgits_giggle:

Got me!

 

[Cartervol]

I haven't seen anything that suggest Butch's in game coaching is any better than Dooley's.. I'd rate him in the bottom 3rd of SEC coaches. Near the top of the bottom 3rd if it makes you feel any better.

 

[IndianapolisVol]

2

 

[TGVol]

Recruiting 7, coaching 1.

 

[bnhunt]

5.5 overall.
8.5 - recruiting
8.0 - program salesman
3.0 - gameday coach

 

[DownNDirty]

Dooley was a better X and O coach than Jones. He was a walking disaster but he was a better football coach IMO. And he beat the snot out of CBJ's Cincinnati team 45-23. It was Dooley's signature win during his time here.

On a scale of Dooley to Saban Jones is far closer to Dooley than most would like to admit.

 

[Madscientistvol]

How bout lets play what SEC coach is Butch better than....

Mason at Vandy
Stoops at Kentucky
Odom at Missouri
Smart at Georgia (could change next year)

Notice, there are only 4 coaches and they are in the East. Butch is in bottom tier in terms of coaching in the SEC.

After yesterday ad Ed Ogeron to that list.

 

[Ty4Vols]

8.0

UT was ranked 19 going into this weekend.

That means there are only 18 teams ranked higher and none of them (0) played a schedule as strong as UT's.

Now at 8-3 and they will improve in their rankings.

CBJ has room to improve but seeing people say between 2-6 is ridiculous.

 

[Top Gun]

8.0

UT was ranked 19 going into this weekend.

That means there are only 18 teams ranked higher and none of them (0) played a schedule as strong as UT's.

Now at 8-3 and they will improve in their rankings.

CBJ has room to improve but seeing people say between 2-6 is ridiculous.

This ^ Exactly!!!

 

[Top Gun]

5.5 overall.
8.5 - recruiting
8.0 - program salesman
3.0 - gameday coach

Need to work on our math skills bunny hunter.