Recruiting Forum Football Talk XXIV

[BleedingButch]

Who was?

AJ McCarron

 

[jspvol76]

Who was?

To play devil's advocate - Newton, Tebow, Wuerffel are a few.

 

[chavisut]

To play devil's advocate - Newton, Tebow, Wuerffel are a few.

Peyton was more ready as a freshman and better than all three.

 

[tomq_123]

GOAT

Broncos QB Peyton Manning pens touching letter to Carr family

 

[jasonvol18]

Who was?

Based off Championships,Heisman etc you would have to say Tebow was the better college QB. But if you base it off stats and record it is obviously Peyton. Depends on what you want to go with.

 

[jspvol76]

Peyton was more ready as a freshman and better than all three.

k:

 

[jasonvol18]

Peyton was more ready as a freshman and better than all three.

Overall then yes absolutely.. But if you go by Championships and He is man Trophy's then maybe not. But a if you go by college and pro career then Peyton is one of the best ever.

 

[KBVol]

How old are you?

Not very.

 

[jspvol76]

From 247

Danny Wuerffel is the definitive best quarterback since the early expansion of the SEC,and maybe the best all-time. He collected four straight SEC titles, unseated Heisman candidate Terry Dean in his freshman season, won the Heisman in 1996 and capped off his career with a National Championship over hated rival Florida State.

Career Statistics: 708-1170 (60.5%) for 10,875 yards (114 TD/42 INT)

 

[chavisut]

From 247

Danny Wuerffel is the definitive best quarterback since the early expansion of the SEC,and maybe the best all-time. He collected four straight SEC titles, unseated Heisman candidate Terry Dean in his freshman season, won the Heisman in 1996 and capped off his career with a National Championship over hated rival Florida State.

From chavis

Peyton was better.

 

[jspvol76]

From chavis

Peyton was better.

Definitely had a better arm.

 

[The Breakerboy]

He was outside of the Florida games. For some reason he became turnover prone against UF.that and losing to Memphis cost us chances to play for more SEC Championships and to play for NC's when Peyton was at UT.

Was Peyton a better "college" QB than Tebow?

 

[jasonvol18]

From chavis

Peyton was better.

I love Peyton but Wuerffel was the better college QB. Won the Heisman,won more SEC Championships,National Championships and beat us regularly. Bad as it hurts to admit Peyton didn't come close to what Danny did and Peyton played for the more talented teams. Spurrier was just a way better coach than Fulmer.

 

[InVOLuntary]

It's my opinion you can't judge a qb based solely on his teams success.

 

[Dust10]

Was Peyton a better "college" QB than Tebow?

I think there is a decent consensus Tebow had the best collegiate career in the history of the SEC and Newton had the best single season for a QB in SEC history.

 

[The Breakerboy]

I love Peyton but Wuerffel was the better college QB. Won the Heisman,won more SEC Championships,National Championships and beat us regularly. Bad as it hurts to admit Peyton didn't come close to what Danny did and Peyton played for the more talented teams. Spurrier was just a way better coach than Fulmer.

They compare Pro Peyton to the college guys.

 

[chavisut]

Was Jason White better too?

 

[chavisut]

They compare Pro Peyton to the college guys.

Nope. Peyton was the most talented QB to play in the SEC. Newton probably the best since.

 

[The Breakerboy]

I think there is a decent consensus Tebow had the best collegiate career in the history of the SEC and Newton had the best single season for a QB in SEC history.

With Berry there's no one to even compare to him at safety. He was a Heisman candidate going into his junior year.

 

[jasonvol18]

Was Peyton a better "college" QB than Tebow?

Based off Heisman and Championships yes Tebow was better. based off overall stats then Peyton was in a whole different QB class just like he is as an NFL QB.

 

[The Breakerboy]

Nope. Peyton was the most talented QB to play in the SEC. Newton probably the best since.

Peyton isn't more talented than Newton. What?????

 

[BJHSVol]

Based off Heisman and Championships yes Tebow was better. based off overall stats then Peyton was in a whole different QB class just like he is as an NFL QB.

Based off stats Tebow did things that no other QB had done before

 

[RockyTopInBham]

Was Peyton a better "college" QB than Tebow?

College QB, yes. College competitor/leader, no. JMO.

 

[The Breakerboy]

Based off stats Tebow did things that no other QB had done before

This....... Johnny Football and Cam came after Tebow set the new standard.

 

[jspvol76]

If I had a choice, and if picking a QB today to run my college offense based on their ability in college, I would pick Newton. Flame away.