I think maybe at first you might, but at the same time you might get a 2 loss Florida team whose players don’t opt out taking on a 2 seed Clemson at Clemson. There’s no way you could convince me that both teams wouldn’t have an entertaining game and that it wouldn’t be competitive. I think matchups would be key in those games, plus not giving teams a month to prepare and recover all of their guys.
If the PAC 12 could get their stuff together and actually field a very good team it would be fun to see a PAC12 team host a playoff game against an SEC or ACC school. I think the intrigue of the potential matchups and the reward of a home playoff game keeps the regular season relevant and would drive the interest in an expanded CFP. And in all honesty, I really don’t care about the Cinderella G5 schools having a guaranteed opportunity. I’m sure everyone would be banging the drum for the little guy because everyone loves a good story, but I think that’s where the blowouts would happen, when Coastal has to go to Tuscaloosa or Columbus.