Who's Your Heisman Winner?

#1
robvols

robvols

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
2,956
Likes
0
#1
All right guys, it's coming up in a few days but who is your Heisman winner?

I like the Stanford guy but I have a feeling Ingram may win the coveted trophy; Tebow blowed and cried and McCoy got cornhuskered nine times; don't forget the Husker that participated in the sacking got invited for it.


DISCLAIMER: These votes do not count towards the real Heisman selection process
 
#2
#2
My vote would go to Gerhart, but it will be

1.Ingram
2.McCoy
3.Gerhart
4.Suh
5.Tebow

I hope McCoy can pass Ingram, though.

Left Suh out.
 
Last edited:
#4
#4
Suh is a freak of nature. I have never seen a DT manhandle O-lineman like that. Unfortunately that position won't get much love for the heisman. My vote is for Gerhart
 
#6
#6
the heisman trophy right they have not for years if the did stanford RB should get it because he has more yards and touchdowns than ingram suh is the most dominant football player in college my list would be 1toby 2suh 3mccoy 4ingram 5teblows:the_finger:
 
#8
#8
Colt or Ingram will win it because they are playing for the national title.

Suh or Gerhard deserve it the most though.

Ingram wins.
 
#9
#9
CornPoke said:
Suh is a freak of nature. I have never seen a DT manhandle O-lineman like that. Unfortunately that position won't get much love for the heisman. My vote is for Gerhart
Click to expand...
IMO there are guys like Suh every couple years, that are surefire DT picks in the draft. Guys that you can bank on coming in and being the next Haynesworth. Since I heard about him a lot living here, Haloti Ngata was one of those guys. Suh is better than most, for sure, but not such a huge rarity as most believe.

Suh just managed to get the spotlight since he was about to be the key factor in what would have been the most significant upset of the BCS era. That was, of course, until a place kicker and a defensive back completely ruined it in a matter of seconds.
 
#10
#10
Suh was the best player, but that doesn't mean anything. It's an insult to everybody's intelligence for the media to pretend that either he or Gerhart have a chance, or for the Heisman people to waste their time by flying them to NY. (Although I guess they do get a nice trip out of it.) Ingram will probably win, which is crap. If McCoy disqualified himself on Saturday, then Ingram should have disqualified himself the week before against Auburn. It's ridiculous that Tebow is going to be in NY and has received anybody's first-place vote.
 
#11
#11
milohimself said:
IMO there are guys like Suh every couple years, that are surefire DT picks in the draft. Guys that you can bank on coming in and being the next Haynesworth. Since I heard about him a lot living here, Haloti Ngata was one of those guys. Suh is better than most, for sure, but not such a huge rarity as most believe.

Suh just managed to get the spotlight since he was about to be the key factor in what would have been the most significant upset of the BCS era. That was, of course, until a place kicker and a defensive back completely ruined it in a matter of seconds.
Click to expand...

Maybe you just started paying attention, but people have raving about Suh since he manhandled Missouri on Thursday night two months ago.
 
#12
#12
Vercingetorix said:
Suh was the best player, but that doesn't mean anything. It's an insult to everybody's intelligence for the media to pretend that either he or Gerhart have a chance, or for the Heisman people to waste their time by flying them to NY. (Although I guess they do get a nice trip out of it.) Ingram will probably win, which is crap. If McCoy disqualified himself on Saturday, then Ingram should have disqualified himself the week before against Auburn. It's ridiculous that Tebow is going to be in NY and has received anybody's first-place vote.
Click to expand...
They're flying Tebow out there to give some closing recognition to one of the best collegiate players of all time. While I don't give the media a whole lot of credit, I do give them enough that nobody outside of a 100 mile radius of Gainesville cast a first place vote for Tebow.

Vercingetorix said:
Maybe you just started paying attention, but people have raving about Suh since he manhandled Missouri on Thursday night two months ago.
Click to expand...
I have been paying attention. I live a mile from Suh's high school. I know he's really good, and that he may end up being remembered as one of the best DT's in decades. Alls I'm saying is without the notoriety of the Texas game, if it didn't have the possible implication of sending a non-BCS team to the BCS championship, then he probably wouldn't be getting an invitation to New York.

Still, says a lot. Doing a bit of research, Suh will be the first defensive linemen to garner any votes since Warren Sapp in 94. Impressive.
 
#14
#14
Dont beat yourself up over mentioning Keenum. He's 2 wins a way from being at the top of some lists.
 
#20
#20
robvols said:
You are talking about the Walter Camp Award, which has been dubbed as the precursor to who is going to win the Heisman? Lately it has been proven wrong.
Click to expand...

The last two? runner ups...the previous 3? Heisman winner. Who knows...as long as Ingram n' Tebow dont win...im happy
 
#21
#21
Gerhart or Suh are the most deserving, but we as TN fans know that person doesn't get it. If all years past are any indication, Colt McCoy will get the Heisman since he will be losing the National championship game. Heisman winners usually flop in their bowl games.
 
#22
#22
McCoy probably wins it, but Suh would get my vote. Only problem i have with Ingram is that he really didn't carry that team. They had good backups and a ton of talent around him.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top