I wouldn't. It wasn't even close. It was shorter through the air. P Will had to slow down and got tackled. A better pass he would have hit him in stride for a td. The guy was burnt badly. If that pass was versus a good defense it would have been broken up at least, if not intercepted.
So one is in stride, further through the air, versus SEC first team defense, for a td, while behind.
The other was shorter, he got tackled, versus Southern Conf second or third team defense in a blowout.
Yea, nowhere near as impressive.
1. You know, this stuff is easily checked/researched/verified. Anybody can do it.....You're letting your bias cloud your judgment. That QD throw to PWill was every bit as beautiful a throw as Dobbs' throw to Malone vs Kentucky. Only someone with an agenda would say otherwise.
2. PWill did not have to slow down at all. The ball was thrown to his outside shoulder because he was very well covered to his inside. The ball was perfectly placed, PWill made an outstanding catch and the cornerback then tackled him. Your assessment that a "better pass would've resulted in a TD" is crap and, deep down, beneath your bias, you know it..... just give the kid his due.
3. Actually, as good a throw as Dobbs made to Malone vs Kentucky, his pass was much closer to being intercepted than QD's pass to PWill...it was a very good throw and Josh had excellent focus to catch it....QD's pass, as I mentioned, was beautifully thrown to PWill's outside shoulder next to the sideline, so if PWill hadn't caught it, no one would have.
4. Dobbs' pass traveled 50 yards in the air, QD's 48.....virtually no difference. I'd say nice try, but it wasn't.
5. IMHO, the 3 best throws of the season, in no particular order, were 1. Dobbs' throw to Malone vs Ky for the 75 yd TD.....2. Dobbs' throw to Malone vs SCar which Josh dropped in the endzone......3. Dormady's throw to PWill vs Western Carolina.
Honorable mention: Dobbs' 2 throws vs Bama on our last scoring drive, 1 across the field to Smith, the other a deep post to Malone.
Yeah, QD's throw was every bit as good and impressive as Dobbs'.