I did this comparison last year in a spreadsheet, I've updated it, and here it is including bowl games...
Tennessee Offensive Coordinators (1983-Present)....
Walt Harris ('83-'88)
Overall Record: 47-21-4 (.681)
Bowl Record: 4-1 (.800)
SEC Championships: 1
Rush Yds Avg: 181.6
Pass Yds Avg: 198.1
Total Offense Avg: 379.7
Points Avg: 25.9
Key Players:
QB: Alan Cockrell, Tony Robinson, Jeff Francis
RB: Johnnie Jones, Keith Davis, William Howard, Reggie Cobb
WR: Clyde Duncan, Tim McGee, Joey Clinkscales, Thomas Woods, Terence Cleveland
Phil Fulmer ('89-'92)
Overall Record: 37-9-2 (.792)
Bowl Record: 2-1 (.667)
SEC Championships: 2
Rush Yds Avg: 218.9
Pass Yds Avg: 202.3
Total Offense Avg: 421.2
Points Avg: 30.7
Key Players:
QB: Andy Kelly, Heath Shuler
RB: Reggie Cobb, Chuck Webb, Tony Thompson, James Stewart, Aaron Hayden, Charlie Garner
WR: Thomas Woods, Carl Pickens, Anthony Morgan, Alvin Harper, Corey Fleming
David Cutcliffe ('93-'98)*
Overall Record: 63-11 (.851)
Bowl Record: 4-2 (.667)
SEC Championships: 2
Eastern Division Crowns: 3
Rush Yds Avg: 186.4
Pass Yds Avg: 255.0
Total Offense Avg: 441.4
Points Avg: 35.0
Key Players:
QB: Heath Shuler, Peyton Manning, Tee Martin
RB:Charlie Garner, James Stewart, Aaron Hayden, Jay Graham, Jamal Lewis, Travis Henry, Travis Stephens, Onterrio Smith
WR:Craig Faulkner, Joey Kent, Jermaine Copeland, Peerless Price, Marcus Nash, Cedric Wilson
Randy Sanders ('99-Pres.)**
Overall Record: 54-18 (.740)
Bowl Record: 2-4 (.333)
SEC Championships: 0
Eastern Division Crowns: 2
National Championships: 1
Rush Yds Avg: 156.7
Pass Yds Avg: 223.0
Total Offense Avg: 379.8
Points Avg: 27.4
Key Players:
QB: Tee Martin, Casey Clausen
RB: Jamal Lewis, Travis Henry, Travis Stephens, Cedric Houston
WR: Cedric Wilson, Donte Stallworth, Kelley Washington, James Whitten, James Banks
* Includes 1993 Hall of Fame Bowl
** Includes 1999 Fiesta Bowl