This season is more frustrating than any of the Dooley seasons because at least Dooley's teams weren't even good on paper. On paper, Dooley had teams that should have won, at most, 7 games. He managed 6 one year and 5 in the other two. Disappointing, but those rosters were so depleted/thin you couldn't realistically expect much more.
Butch's best team on paper (last year's team) should have won 10 or 11 regular season games, won the East, and had a chance to win the Sugar Bowl. The 2015 team could/should have won 10 or 11 regular season games too. Talent-wise, this year's squad is capable of winning probably 8 or 9 games. They aren't any worse than LSU.
Butch gets the least out of his players more than perhaps any other coach in the country. The offensive line is full of 4-star players and Trey Smith is a 5-star. The starting defensive line consists of a 5-star (McKenzie), an extremely highly touted 4-star (Tuttle), another highly touted 4-star who was the #1 JUCO in the country (Kongbo), and another 4-star (Taylor). All 4 of those guys could have gone almost anywhere in the country. Collectively, they somehow are just a mediocre defensive line. There's no way each of those guys are just simply underachievers or outright busts. It comes back to coaching and talent development.