Oh an old fave. The Andruw debate.
Him not being in the hall means five tool players are not as highly regarded as folks like to chide about. Before he was 30, and keep in mind he entered the league as a teenager (as well know per his historic WS appearance), he was just a special baseball player.
Andruw is punished for a couple things imho. He diminished greatly after 30, but kept playing, because I think he didn't take juice and he had been playing 12 years in CF with total disregard for his body... I swear every night he caught two balls that not only saved runs but no one else gets to. No one. And this typically ended up with him diving or slamming his body into an outfield wall. Second, he is punished because of his batting avg. Yeah, it's not elite. But if want to take guys out of the hall for a couple things, we can start making lists of all the guys that are in the hall today.
From '97 to '07 he hit 25+ HR each season. .823 career OPS. 10 straight gold gloves. Five time AS. Should have been the MVP in '05 but Pujols had a monster year. Third best WAR from '98 to '07.
After he was 30 he started less than 70 games in CF. His body just fell apart from an elite baseball standard.
The guy pitching here will tell ya all day every day that a huge reason he's in the Hall because this dude was in CF behind him a large portion of his career.