Tennessee football investigation, conference expansion show NCAA's irrelevance

#1

VolForLife83

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2010
Messages
10,494
Likes
12,058
#1
Once the Big Ten and SEC add enough teams to reach super-conference status, the NCAA will become useless. Super conferences can administer themselves. And they can do it better.

They can make their own rules, then enforce them in a fair and swift manner. The NCAA too often has been neither fair nor swift.

The NCAA’s lack of urgency again has been apparent in the case of Tennessee.

For a year and a half, UT’s football program has been under investigation for recruiting violations. It has been drawn out for so long that former coach Jeremy Pruitt has had time to lose a second job – with the New York Giants – since being fired for mismanaging Tennessee’s program at a historical level.

No one expects sudden results from the NCAA, whose motto might as well be “haste makes waste.” But even for a group that invariably crawls its way to conclusions, its sluggish pace has been stunning in this instance.

The exhausting process of fact finding isn’t an excuse. UT did most of the legwork, after which school chancellor Donde Plowman made it painfully clear the program had gone off the NCAA rails with Pruitt at the wheel.

Following UT’s internal investigation, Pruitt and nine staff members were fired in January 2021. Athletics director Phillip Fulmer’s exit was mercifully characterized as “a retirement.”

Plowman blew the whistle on her program and dismissed the perpetrators. Then, she brought in the replacements, headlined by AD Danny White and football coach Josh Heupel.

Heupel revived the football program in his first season, and the entire athletics department is on the ascent under White. So, the mess Pruitt left behind should be nothing more than a bad memory.

Yet the NCAA investigation drags on with seemingly no end in sight. Perhaps, ineptitude isn’t to blame. Maybe, the NCAA infractions committee forgot to put Tennessee on its calendar.

But UT won’t see the humor in that – not when it already has been punished. How could the possibility of NCAA probation not have adversely affected Heupel’s first recruiting class?

That should be punishment enough for a program that unearthed its own violations, cleaned house and threw itself on the mercy of the NCAA court.

Nonetheless, the prolonged investigation at least has reminded us why the NCAA no longer should be in the enforcement business. Let the conferences or super conferences do it.

And let the NCAA just go away, preferably at a faster pace than its investigative proces


Written by your favorite columnist, Mr. John Adams😆

Tennessee football recruiting investigation shows NCAA irrelevant
 
#2
#2
I think Tennessee just needs to sue the AA and continue business as usual. Tennessee has done everything in its power and more to remedy the situation. They fired MULTIPLE people from the top down and MULTIPLE players left the program.

This now falls squarely on the AA and at this rate, since nothing has been done, Tennessee needs to be fully and publicly exonerated and just move on.
 
#3
#3
I think Tennessee just needs to sue the AA and continue business as usual. Tennessee has done everything in its power and more to remedy the situation. They fired MULTIPLE people from the top down and MULTIPLE players left the program.

This now falls squarely on the AA and at this rate, since nothing has been done, Tennessee needs to be fully and publicly exonerated and just move on.

I'm sure they'll give us the finger as a parting gift. Probably be effective in their last year of reign and the year we're rolling
 
#4
#4
UT needs to tell the NCAA where to go and what to do on the way there. The NCAA won't exist, when it comes to D-I football, five years from now.
 
#8
#8
Merge with thread from a few hours ago covering the same topic
 
#9
#9
Once the Big Ten and SEC add enough teams to reach super-conference status, the NCAA will become useless. Super conferences can administer themselves. And they can do it better.

They can make their own rules, then enforce them in a fair and swift manner. The NCAA too often has been neither fair nor swift.

The NCAA’s lack of urgency again has been apparent in the case of Tennessee.

For a year and a half, UT’s football program has been under investigation for recruiting violations. It has been drawn out for so long that former coach Jeremy Pruitt has had time to lose a second job – with the New York Giants – since being fired for mismanaging Tennessee’s program at a historical level.

No one expects sudden results from the NCAA, whose motto might as well be “haste makes waste.” But even for a group that invariably crawls its way to conclusions, its sluggish pace has been stunning in this instance.

The exhausting process of fact finding isn’t an excuse. UT did most of the legwork, after which school chancellor Donde Plowman made it painfully clear the program had gone off the NCAA rails with Pruitt at the wheel.

Following UT’s internal investigation, Pruitt and nine staff members were fired in January 2021. Athletics director Phillip Fulmer’s exit was mercifully characterized as “a retirement.”

Plowman blew the whistle on her program and dismissed the perpetrators. Then, she brought in the replacements, headlined by AD Danny White and football coach Josh Heupel.

Heupel revived the football program in his first season, and the entire athletics department is on the ascent under White. So, the mess Pruitt left behind should be nothing more than a bad memory.

Yet the NCAA investigation drags on with seemingly no end in sight. Perhaps, ineptitude isn’t to blame. Maybe, the NCAA infractions committee forgot to put Tennessee on its calendar.

But UT won’t see the humor in that – not when it already has been punished. How could the possibility of NCAA probation not have adversely affected Heupel’s first recruiting class?

That should be punishment enough for a program that unearthed its own violations, cleaned house and threw itself on the mercy of the NCAA court.

Nonetheless, the prolonged investigation at least has reminded us why the NCAA no longer should be in the enforcement business. Let the conferences or super conferences do it.

And let the NCAA just go away, preferably at a faster pace than its investigative proces


Written by your favorite columnist, Mr. John Adams😆

Tennessee football recruiting investigation shows NCAA irrelevant

This statement stood out so much I just scanned the rest. This smacks of the situation we are now in with reference to the adoration issue that has been created by the supreme court that turns the law over to the states. They (the states) go there own way, no unity from one "line in the sand to another". This is what super conferences will become, making their own rules that will be to their advantage.
 
#10
#10
Once the Big Ten and SEC add enough teams to reach super-conference status, the NCAA will become useless. Super conferences can administer themselves. And they can do it better.

They can make their own rules, then enforce them in a fair and swift manner. The NCAA too often has been neither fair nor swift.

The NCAA’s lack of urgency again has been apparent in the case of Tennessee.

For a year and a half, UT’s football program has been under investigation for recruiting violations. It has been drawn out for so long that former coach Jeremy Pruitt has had time to lose a second job – with the New York Giants – since being fired for mismanaging Tennessee’s program at a historical level.

No one expects sudden results from the NCAA, whose motto might as well be “haste makes waste.” But even for a group that invariably crawls its way to conclusions, its sluggish pace has been stunning in this instance.

The exhausting process of fact finding isn’t an excuse. UT did most of the legwork, after which school chancellor Donde Plowman made it painfully clear the program had gone off the NCAA rails with Pruitt at the wheel.

Following UT’s internal investigation, Pruitt and nine staff members were fired in January 2021. Athletics director Phillip Fulmer’s exit was mercifully characterized as “a retirement.”

Plowman blew the whistle on her program and dismissed the perpetrators. Then, she brought in the replacements, headlined by AD Danny White and football coach Josh Heupel.

Heupel revived the football program in his first season, and the entire athletics department is on the ascent under White. So, the mess Pruitt left behind should be nothing more than a bad memory.

Yet the NCAA investigation drags on with seemingly no end in sight. Perhaps, ineptitude isn’t to blame. Maybe, the NCAA infractions committee forgot to put Tennessee on its calendar.

But UT won’t see the humor in that – not when it already has been punished. How could the possibility of NCAA probation not have adversely affected Heupel’s first recruiting class?

That should be punishment enough for a program that unearthed its own violations, cleaned house and threw itself on the mercy of the NCAA court.

Nonetheless, the prolonged investigation at least has reminded us why the NCAA no longer should be in the enforcement business. Let the conferences or super conferences do it.

And let the NCAA just go away, preferably at a faster pace than its investigative proces


Written by your favorite columnist, Mr. John Adams😆

Tennessee football recruiting investigation shows NCAA irrelevant


The length of the investigation isn’t a bad thing. It’s apparently not hurting recruiting, players are now getting paid, the NCAA is s losing its grip. Self imposed sanctions will probably be the harshest pu ishment received.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VOLfrombama
#11
#11
Part of our penalty from the NCAA has been the bad officiating we get week to week. I mean they at the very least cost us the Music City bowl.
 
#12
#12
The length of the investigation isn’t a bad thing. It’s apparently not hurting recruiting, players are now getting paid, the NCAA is s losing its grip. Self imposed sanctions will probably be the harshest pu ishment received.
I agree. I'm not sure the NCAA can really do much else except maybe a bowl ban. I was all for giving up the bowl game last year just for that reason as I expect us to go to a little better bowl this year.

I would feel much differently had Plowman not stepped up and cleaned house.
 
Advertisement



Back
Top