voted for TDKR. but i really, really l iked GOG as well.
i just remember walking out of the theater after watching TDKR and thinking "whoa, that was awesome".....now, years later, after picking it apart, i can see some definite big holes in that movie that i just accepted when i first saw it. which is fine.
regardless, as much as i liked GOG, i didn't walk out of the theater feeling the way i did about tdkr....