Wow, I totally disagree with most of you. DM is freakin' awesome. It makes up for everything from The Black Album through St. Anger. Not that I hated all that....well St. Anger pretty much, but DM sounds like the album that should have come out after Justice.
DM has some pretty awesome songs. "The Day That Never Comes" freakin rocks, it has a great "One" vide to it; so does "All Nightmare Long", "Broken Beat & Scarred", "That Was Just Your Life", and "Cyanide". The weakest songs are "Unforgiven 3" (yeah they went there) and "Judas Kiss" but even both of those I pretty much like. Heck they even put an instrumental on there, which also freakin rocks, "Suicide and Redemption".
I mean everyone has their opinion, but to me it's up there with Justice, which is my favorite Metallica album. And while I'm a Metallica fan, I'm not a homer fan that automatically loves everything they put out. The Black Album is way overrated, Load is ehhh..., and ReLoad I actually liked a bit better than Load.