Nunley was a late bloomer, didn't really emerge as a legitimate D1 prospect until the summer after her sophomore year of high school. Didn't get a ton of offers until later that year. She was in the same class as Erin Gabriel, who was the #1 or #2 pitcher in the country that year, depending on whose list you looked at. Gabriel had been committed as a HS freshman. Nunley wanted to come to Tennessee, but there was no scholarship money left in that class by the time she became a real prospect, particularly not for a pitcher with Gabriel already in the class. Kentucky only had enough money because they had a couple of players in the class two years ahead of her leave after their freshman years.
Of course, Gabriel had the hip injury during her freshman year and couldn't throw a softball for almost 9 months, so it took until her senior year before she was "back" and was on a pitch count her entire career. Nunley had a great career at Kentucky. Worked out for everyone.