Wringing hands over this situation makes no sense to me. We are not losing any studs here. If we had a stable of studs coming in, then no BBB petition would have seen the light of day.
Great recruiting covers a multitude of actual season sins. Two proofs to back this up:
#1 Butch (5-7/No Bowl/USA by a shoestring / 3 blowouts / Can't Beat Vandy @ home) Jones.
#2 Butch (Top 5 Ranked Class / Giant 31 player legacy class / 14 EE class / Studs for 15' / "65K" for O-W game / 99% approval rating / He Gets It) Jones
We love the guy b/c it's obvious the future is bright. Conversely, in hoops, it was becoming obvious deep into the season that the future was NOT bright. Weak incoming class and on court disaster with a great roster. Fans, paying attention, are seeing the future not only the present.
As always, seeing the present is what the national media sees in the Cuonzo Martin situation. "UT fans filed a petition to fire a coach who took them to the Sweet 16" they say. No, the future was looking bleak. This class (and the others basically) said CCM was not going to compete with UK & UF. Recruiting is the future.
Forget CCM/CBP/CDT for a moment. What is it that we (UT family) are really after in the future? A trip to the NCAA every other year on average? One win or a S16 every 5-6 years? IMO, Heck No!
We need to be finding a way to get into the elite of cbb. We have a ridiculously rabid and relentlessly loyal fan base. Our facilities are freaking sick. We're in a power conference that's weak at the moment, but still just had 3 in the S16, 2 in FF, and one in the finals. East TN is gorgeous and the girls are too. Nothing and I mean nothing forbids us from being in the elite of cbb. Not even "were a football school". So are OSU, UM and UF. They found a way to be elite (generally) in both.
Not trying to make this about Pearl, but I think a reporter who asked Grunfeld a question, got to the heart of this matter. Before we played Memphis, he asked Earnie if he were surprised that CBP had taken UT all the way to #2 in the nation. Earnie replied "I'm surprised that he's not already #1". Good, bad, or ugly, that guy was going about becoming a champion. Wow!
This is crux folks! Why does the mindset seem to be about "maintaining mediocrity plus"? We are not trapped in a cbb caste system. But, we seem trapped in a fans / AD / admins mindset though. 100 years ago UK, Duke, UL, UNC, UCLA, UConn, Arizona, IU, OSU did not have one stitch of championship history. The point is, it is NOT a prerequisite to getting championship history (see UF). History makes it easier, yes. But, the more difficult the ascent, the greater the glory on top!
Back to the point. Why flip out over some 2-3 star players who decommit? We weren't winning the SEC with those guys folks. You HAVE to have some studs to win titles. If CDT is the guy to take us to the mountain top, then he may flop this cycle and just get back 1 or 2 similar rated guys. So what. Save the schollies and knock the next 2 years classes outta the park (CBJ style) with JUCOs and/or elite players.
If we don't have a coach that can sell this place to elite talent, then we still don't have the right guy. But, wringing hands over possibly losing mediocrity is a waste of time.
Sorry for the looong rant.