Religion forum?

a difference to you and me, sure. to God? I am not sure. this is one of the things I haven't nailed down in my faith.

Catholics believe in death bed confessionals, as long as there was repentance God, who loves us, will "accept" it, but we are called to live as better people, so I can see the argument from both sides.

I think it comes down to are they taking advantage of their non-repentance by design, or are they literally just uncaring/unknowing about the sin?
The parable of the workmen , some who agreed to work all day , and those who only worked the last hour got the same pay. The thief on the cross. It is about faith.
Whosoever will? God knows the heart ; knows before we do how we will decide concerning Jesus and is not willing that any should perish .
 
  • Like
Reactions: orangebloodgmc
@marcusluvsvols
You responded to a post in a thread that a mod moved my post to…..the religious forum.. that I’m not allowed to post in. I’m actually banned from that thread for unpopular opinions. You see a Baptist preacher who I have on ignore said something to me and they banned me from that thread.

Too Jewish for Christianity I guess (that’s a joke. Don’t get all huffy my dear moderators)

But to answer your question.

The translators did more damage than good and actually sinned against G-d by changing the name of messiah.

For example there’s a verse that says “you shall call his name Jesus for he will save his people from their sins”. To Jewish people that’s nonsense as names are very important. I’ve had fellow Jews point out how Jesus could not be their messiah as the name of messiah would matter. That’s when I point out that “Jesus “ is an English translation corruption. The Messiahs name was “Yeshua” which to every Jew , especially at that time, means “YHWH is Salvation” just like the other heroes of Torah named “Joshua”, they were Saviors sent by the G-d of A, I,and J.

I hope you enjoy your sabbath with your family and friends today my brother
Have you posted recently in the newest pub religion forum? If so, did not realize anyone had been banned. It is mostly from a Christian perspective, but would really be interested in the expectations of what the Messiah was to accomplish. I had heard and read that the Messiah was both a suffering , acquainted with grief, as well as a conquering Messiah, to fullfill Gods ultimate plans.
What names were used in in the prophecies in the original language? and in the times of Christ ? The pharasees and religious leaders seemed to against Him the most.
 
Have you posted recently in the newest pub religion forum? If so, did not realize anyone had been banned. It is mostly from a Christian perspective, but would really be interested in the expectations of what the Messiah was to accomplish. I had heard and read that the Messiah was both a suffering , acquainted with grief, as well as a conquering Messiah, to fullfill Gods ultimate plans.
What names were used in in the prophecies in the original language? and in the times of Christ ? The pharasees and religious leaders seemed to against Him the most.
I can be prickly. We had a church of Christ guy who I felt was being disrespectful and dishonest so I rode him pretty hard. The Baptist preacher was just different. He had the “you can be wrong if you want so you’re going to hell” I do not believe scripture teaches eternal suffering for mortals. If you are not righteous you receive the death penalty for a second time.
I can support that with scripture if you like but it’s not a conversation where anyone is trying to convince the other they’re wrong. I’m not interested in that. All I care about is what I believe. I’m willing to share that but I’m completely ok if you disagree with me.

In the thread you are playing in I told Louder he wasn’t going to hell. The other guy responded. I have him on ignore so I never saw it. Freak said he wasn’t putting up with us again in that thread. Which I’m fine with. It’s his site and I like it here.
(Even if I pick at Freak from time to time. He knows I’m playing. I’ve been around a while. )

Hope that clears things up.
 
I can be prickly. We had a church of Christ guy who I felt was being disrespectful and dishonest so I rode him pretty hard. The Baptist preacher was just different. He had the “you can be wrong if you want so you’re going to hell” I do not believe scripture teaches eternal suffering for mortals. If you are not righteous you receive the death penalty for a second time.
I can support that with scripture if you like but it’s not a conversation where anyone is trying to convince the other they’re wrong. I’m not interested in that. All I care about is what I believe. I’m willing to share that but I’m completely ok if you disagree with me.

In the thread you are playing in I told Louder he wasn’t going to hell. The other guy responded. I have him on ignore so I never saw it. Freak said he wasn’t putting up with us again in that thread. Which I’m fine with. It’s his site and I like it here.
(Even if I pick at Freak from time to time. He knows I’m playing. I’ve been around a while. )

Hope that clears things up.

O.K.was hoping I wasn't part of the resson.
There is a verse about seeing as through a glass darkly in the n.t. There are always those who seem to forget this ; have all the answers .Maybe comparable to the Pharasees.
We are all travellers through life, learning as we go.

Seek truth. I have always believed that what God reveals to us will always be in line with core teachings and truth of His word.We each may get different answers , depending our circumstances , but all line up with core tenets of His word.

Seems this verse applies well to the entire Bible.

2 Timothy 2:15​


“Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.”
 
Opinions vary. I’m Jewish so I will likely have a different perspective than most. 53 is complicated. As is the identity of the suffering servant that is referenced many times throughout Isiah. Sometimes it’s the nation of Israel. Sometimes it’s Messiah. Sometimes it’s both.
I’m in the camp that some of 53 ….might even call it most …..is speaking of Messiah.
Isaiah is one of my favorite O.T. books , along with Psalms. The Dead Sea scrolls copy of Isaiah is almost comp!ete and very close to what we read today isn't it?

I had not noticed until it was pointed out to me by , don't remember , but psalm 22 seems to describe crucifixion. I was at the emergency room and the doctor actually described the physical effects . The cause of death is gradual suffocation., hence the breaking of the legs to hasten the process.
I appreciate the conversation , thanks.
 
I can be prickly. We had a church of Christ guy who I felt was being disrespectful and dishonest so I rode him pretty hard. The Baptist preacher was just different. He had the “you can be wrong if you want so you’re going to hell” I do not believe scripture teaches eternal suffering for mortals. If you are not righteous you receive the death penalty for a second time.
I can support that with scripture if you like but it’s not a conversation where anyone is trying to convince the other they’re wrong. I’m not interested in that. All I care about is what I believe. I’m willing to share that but I’m completely ok if you disagree with me.

In the thread you are playing in I told Louder he wasn’t going to hell. The other guy responded. I have him on ignore so I never saw it. Freak said he wasn’t putting up with us again in that thread. Which I’m fine with. It’s his site and I like it here.
(Even if I pick at Freak from time to time. He knows I’m playing. I’ve been around a while. )

Hope that clears things up.
can you explain why you think hell isn’t biblical? Do you think it’s misrepresenting Gehenna?
 
I can be prickly. We had a church of Christ guy who I felt was being disrespectful and dishonest so I rode him pretty hard. The Baptist preacher was just different. He had the “you can be wrong if you want so you’re going to hell” I do not believe scripture teaches eternal suffering for mortals. If you are not righteous you receive the death penalty for a second time.
I can support that with scripture if you like but it’s not a conversation where anyone is trying to convince the other they’re wrong. I’m not interested in that. All I care about is what I believe. I’m willing to share that but I’m completely ok if you disagree with me.

In the thread you are playing in I told Louder he wasn’t going to hell. The other guy responded. I have him on ignore so I never saw it. Freak said he wasn’t putting up with us again in that thread. Which I’m fine with. It’s his site and I like it here.
(Even if I pick at Freak from time to time. He knows I’m playing. I’ve been around a while. )

Hope that clears things up.
Hey, long as your aren't confusing me with that other CoC guy, or the Baptist preacher. lol. What I find ironic, maybe even humorous, is that the ones that argue fervently with you to prove you wrong haven't had enough beneficial debate with you to realize that being Messianic and not what us other folk think is Jewish, you're beliefs in totality are more akin to what a CoC person may beleive with a few exceptions. So much so, that you allowed your kids to attend CoC private schools in Chatt and point blank said you had no issue with what they taught them. Funny how folk can stand on hte same side of hte creek when their not throwing rocks at each other. As we both know from long and tedious conversations, Messianic basically being essentially the same as the new testament early christians where they converted to Pauls message of God, but still held some traditional practices, which you would be descended. Matter of fact, you and I have probably found more common ground in our beliefs than we have debated differences. But, I do try to base my CoC upbringing not along accepted party lines, but as much on what is actually said as I can intepret and understand. Which is a break away for most, regardless of where you attend. If I say I (we) follow the scripture only, but I fall in line with historical practice/belief without my own study with God, do I not then render myself denominational by defualt. Thought you'd enjoy a little diatribe since you're not in exile in here yet. lol.

However, I do believe the 2nd death and "eternal" are one in the same, just as heaven would be "eternal." So then would be condemnation.

A final thought since we are in the Jewish/Israel Political Thread, is that roughly 90% of hte time, maybe more, there is little discernable difference between politics and religion. The historical heiarchies of both politcal structure and traditional denominational structure are quite similar and sleep in the same bed. Lot's of sin and death have eminated from both throughout history in the name of God and the annointed's. Church folk were some of the most accomplished lynchers in the earlier days of our own history.
 
Last edited:
Hey, long as your aren't confusing me with that other CoC guy, or the Baptist preacher. lol. What I find ironic, maybe even humorous, is that the ones that argue fervently with you to prove you wrong haven't had enough beneficial debate with you to realize that being Messianic and not what us other folk think is Jewish, you're beliefs in totality are more akin to what a CoC person may beleive with a few exceptions. So much so, that you allowed your kids to attend CoC private schools in Chatt and point blank said you had no issue with what they taught them. Funny how folk can stand on hte same side of hte creek when their not throwing rocks at each other. As we both know from long and tedious conversations, Messianic basically being essentially the same as the new testament early christians where they converted to Pauls message of God, but still held some traditional practices, which you would be descended. Matter of fact, you and I have probably found more common ground in our beliefs than we have debated differences. But, I do try to base my CoC upbringing not along accepted party lines, but as much on what is actually said as I can intepret and understand. Which is a break away for most, regardless of where you attend. If I say I (we) follow the scripture only, but I fall in line with historical practice/belief without my own study with God, do I not then render myself denominational by defualt. Thought you'd enjoy a little diatribe since you're not in exile in here yet. lol.

However, I do believe the 2nd death and "eternal" are one in the same, just as heaven would be "eternal." So then would be condemnation.

A final thought since we are in the Jewish/Israel Political Thread, is that roughly 90% of hte time, maybe more, there is little discernable difference between politics and religion. The historical heiarchies of both politcal structure and traditional denominational structure are quite similar and sleep in the same bed. Lot's of sin and death have eminated from both throughout history in the name of God and the annointed's. Church folk were some of the most accomplished lynchers in the earlier days of our own history.

Obviously I am not Slice, but good post. I learned much about Judaism from him and the existence of messianic which I did not even know existed prior to meeting him here. My kids are both Bible nerds and still take courses (and teach some) on scripture so we have pretty lively discussions because I believe slightly different than either my son or daughter. We put them thru a Christian School my son for 13years and my daughter 11...both finished while doing dual enrollment with Liberty U. We have always attended Baptist churches, but do not claim to be Baptists, or any other denomination. We chose independent Baptist churches that strictly adhere to Scripture, not members of the Southern Baptist organization which forces you to use their Sunday school books and other literature. We have always encouraged both kids to develop their OWN beliefs, which may differ slightly from ours on some details, as long as they know WHY they believe it and can "defend" their stance with scripture. It has made for some heated (but friendly ofc) debates about some things, but it also has kept them constantly seeking His face...wanting to know Him more and His Word verbatim. They both have a far better knowledge of God's word than I do, and are much better people too. Mission accomplished so far. 😃

From my talks with Slice, he seems like a good Christian that chooses to keep the Law of the OT as a sign of obedience to God. I agree with you that his beliefs have way more in common with ours than most others...I think moreso probably than Mormonism and probably Catholicism too. I admire their discipline and dedication to try and keep the Law as best they can. Its impressive as an undertaking IMO. If I remember correctly the only part really where our beliefs differ is I think Slice may reject all the letters from Paul to the various churches? Which we do not, and accept them as part of God's word. I don't want to put words in his mouth though, so I am not 100% sure about that. I am sure he will clarify, or you may already know from your discussions with him which are likely years more recent than mine. Either way, I respect his opinions and him as a person. I have had some lengthy discussions with my kids wherein I discussed things which Slice and I had talked about previously. I find it very interesting, I wasnt raised Christian but came to God in 2003 at 26yo so I have a lot of catching up to do. Great post from you and thanks for your input bud.
 
can you explain why you think hell isn’t biblical? Do you think it’s misrepresenting Gehenna?
Very much like trying to prove a negative is difficult. My position isn’t easy to put in a short answer. My position is there is no scripture support for the concepts of mortals going to hell. First let me break down the why then I’ll let you have your say.

We are taught the we are corruptible in our current state and put on incorruptible/righteousness after the judgment. It happens once.

1 Cor 15
For this [a]perishable must put on [b]the imperishable, and this mortal must put on immortality. 54 But when this [c]perishable puts on [d]the imperishable, and this mortal puts on immortality, then will come about the saying that is written: “Death has been swallowed up in victory.55 Where, O Death, is your victory? Where, O Death, is your sting?”

(I could go down the rabbit hole on what is being said here but I’ll refrain for now)

So nobody is immortal and only the righteous/saved becomes immortal.
So when does this transformation happen for those who believe.
We call it the great white throne judgment.

Judgment at the Throne of God​

11 Then I saw a great white throne and Him who sat upon it, from whose [g]presence earth and heaven fled, and no place was found for them. 12 And I saw the dead, the great and the small, standing before the throne, and [h]books were opened; and another [i]book was opened, which is the book of life; and the dead were judged from the things which were written in the [j]books, according to their deeds.13 And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, and Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them; and they were judged, each one of themaccording to their deeds. 14 Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. 15 And if [k]anyone’s name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire.


Again. Not immortal unless you put on immortality. To put on immortality you have to be righteous. If you’re not righteous you’re corruptible when thrown into the fire which is the 2nd and final death.

The challenge becomes to find and scripture that says the unrighteous live on forever in torment. Because so far I haven’t been able to find it.

Your turn
 
IIRC, and he will correct if I am wrong. But I don't think its the existence of hell he questions. but who/what goes there and why.
Or….. who is capable of surviving it.
The fallen are immortal and the place was created as a prison for them. Mortals are thrown there and destroyed as a final punishment but are not made immortal before hand
 
Hey, long as your aren't confusing me with that other CoC guy, or the Baptist preacher. lol. What I find ironic, maybe even humorous, is that the ones that argue fervently with you to prove you wrong haven't had enough beneficial debate with you to realize that being Messianic and not what us other folk think is Jewish, you're beliefs in totality are more akin to what a CoC person may beleive with a few exceptions. So much so, that you allowed your kids to attend CoC private schools in Chatt and point blank said you had no issue with what they taught them. Funny how folk can stand on hte same side of hte creek when their not throwing rocks at each other. As we both know from long and tedious conversations, Messianic basically being essentially the same as the new testament early christians where they converted to Pauls message of God, but still held some traditional practices, which you would be descended. Matter of fact, you and I have probably found more common ground in our beliefs than we have debated differences. But, I do try to base my CoC upbringing not along accepted party lines, but as much on what is actually said as I can intepret and understand. Which is a break away for most, regardless of where you attend. If I say I (we) follow the scripture only, but I fall in line with historical practice/belief without my own study with God, do I not then render myself denominational by defualt. Thought you'd enjoy a little diatribe since you're not in exile in here yet. lol.

However, I do believe the 2nd death and "eternal" are one in the same, just as heaven would be "eternal." So then would be condemnation.

A final thought since we are in the Jewish/Israel Political Thread, is that roughly 90% of hte time, maybe more, there is little discernable difference between politics and religion. The historical heiarchies of both politcal structure and traditional denominational structure are quite similar and sleep in the same bed. Lot's of sin and death have eminated from both throughout history in the name of God and the annointed's. Church folk were some of the most accomplished lynchers in the earlier days of our own history.
My Referring to that guy as COC was just the denomination he represented. He was clearly not a fair representation of the denomination as a whole.

My children did attend a COC school in Chattanooga by the name of Boyd Buchanan. The education and extracurricular activities were top notch. I do not regret it at all. I was able to have honest conversations with my children as we went about the differences it the denomination beliefs and ours. I’ve always taught them that your beliefs don’t have to align with anyone else as you are only responsible for yourself at the judgment. It makes it easy to discuss things that way.
Have your beliefs and hold the dear while having respect for others and allowing them to do the same
 
Very much like trying to prove a negative is difficult. My position isn’t easy to put in a short answer. My position is there is no scripture support for the concepts of mortals going to hell. First let me break down the why then I’ll let you have your say.

We are taught the we are corruptible in our current state and put on incorruptible/righteousness after the judgment. It happens once.

1 Cor 15
For this [a]perishable must put on [b]the imperishable, and this mortal must put on immortality. 54 But when this [c]perishable puts on [d]the imperishable, and this mortal puts on immortality, then will come about the saying that is written: “Death has been swallowed up in victory.55 Where, O Death, is your victory? Where, O Death, is your sting?”

(I could go down the rabbit hole on what is being said here but I’ll refrain for now)

So nobody is immortal and only the righteous/saved becomes immortal.
So when does this transformation happen for those who believe.
We call it the great white throne judgment.

Judgment at the Throne of God​

11 Then I saw a great white throne and Him who sat upon it, from whose [g]presence earth and heaven fled, and no place was found for them. 12 And I saw the dead, the great and the small, standing before the throne, and [h]books were opened; and another [i]book was opened, which is the book of life; and the dead were judged from the things which were written in the [j]books, according to their deeds.13 And the sea gave up the dead who were in it, and Death and Hades gave up the dead who were in them; and they were judged, each one of themaccording to their deeds. 14 Then Death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. 15 And if [k]anyone’s name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire.


Again. Not immortal unless you put on immortality. To put on immortality you have to be righteous. If you’re not righteous you’re corruptible when thrown into the fire which is the 2nd and final death.

The challenge becomes to find and scripture that says the unrighteous live on forever in torment. Because so far I haven’t been able to find it.

Your turn

Or….. who is capable of surviving it.
The fallen are immortal and the place was created as a prison for them. Mortals are thrown there and destroyed as a final punishment but are not made immortal before hand

But what about.......

And what about.........

I thought that.......

Nm, Into my second Guiness and Chambord (Its like a chocolate raspberry!) here on St. Paddy's Day, so this will have to wait. ;)

(Seriously, it is likely an interesting discussion, and neither of us would get banned for discussing it, but ultimately, I am more like an "RC Sproul on seeing Billy Graham in heaven" kinda guy - all that matters is what matters, the rest is just people being people.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Orangeslice13
Obviously I am not Slice, but good post. I learned much about Judaism from him and the existence of messianic which I did not even know existed prior to meeting him here. My kids are both Bible nerds and still take courses (and teach some) on scripture so we have pretty lively discussions because I believe slightly different than either my son or daughter. We put them thru a Christian School my son for 13years and my daughter 11...both finished while doing dual enrollment with Liberty U. We have always attended Baptist churches, but do not claim to be Baptists, or any other denomination. We chose independent Baptist churches that strictly adhere to Scripture, not members of the Southern Baptist organization which forces you to use their Sunday school books and other literature. We have always encouraged both kids to develop their OWN beliefs, which may differ slightly from ours on some details, as long as they know WHY they believe it and can "defend" their stance with scripture. It has made for some heated (but friendly ofc) debates about some things, but it also has kept them constantly seeking His face...wanting to know Him more and His Word verbatim. They both have a far better knowledge of God's word than I do, and are much better people too. Mission accomplished so far. 😃

From my talks with Slice, he seems like a good Christian that chooses to keep the Law of the OT as a sign of obedience to God. I agree with you that his beliefs have way more in common with ours than most others...I think moreso probably than Mormonism and probably Catholicism too. I admire their discipline and dedication to try and keep the Law as best they can. Its impressive as an undertaking IMO. If I remember correctly the only part really where our beliefs differ is I think Slice may reject all the letters from Paul to the various churches? Which we do not, and accept them as part of God's word. I don't want to put words in his mouth though, so I am not 100% sure about that. I am sure he will clarify, or you may already know from your discussions with him which are likely years more recent than mine. Either way, I respect his opinions and him as a person. I have had some lengthy discussions with my kids wherein I discussed things which Slice and I had talked about previously. I find it very interesting, I wasnt raised Christian but came to God in 2003 at 26yo so I have a lot of catching up to do. Great post from you and thanks for your input bud.
Slice believes……

There is the G-d of A,I,and J. And the Messiah whom He sent.
The only begotten of G-d. I do not believe in a Trinity. The Holy sprit is simply the working of G-d the father.
An analogy I use is if G-d is fire the Yeshua would be an ember of the fire. The unique and only ember. The very DNA of the father but not the father. All is given to him by the father. He’s our advocate and kindsmen redeemer before G-d at our judgement.


The law is both a blessing and can be a curse. The law is still the definition of sin. Adherence to the law doesn’t save you but it does please G-d. Psalms 119 is a picture of what that looks like.

I believe Paul, like Yeshua was a teacher of the law. Show me any teachings of either and I’ll show you what he’s teaching in Torah

I reject Hebrews as scripture. It wasn’t written by Paul or any of the 12. It contains too may errors to be scripture.

I very much enjoy these conversations as we are called to refine our faith like silver. The way to do that is to heat it up and beat the impurities off of it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: marcusluvsvols
But what about.......

And what about.........

I thought that.......

Nm, Into my second Guiness and Chambord (Its like a chocolate raspberry!) here on St. Paddy's Day, so this will have to wait. ;)

(Seriously, it is likely an interesting discussion, and neither of us would get banned for discussing it, but ultimately, I am more like an "RC Sproul on seeing Billy Graham in heaven" kinda guy - all that matters is what matters, the rest is just people being people.)
You are definitely up for this conversation…..when the time is right
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ritzwatch
Hey y'all I'm having some trouble with God right now. I accept Jesus Christ as my lord and savior and all that, I absolutely believe in a higher power. But I have noticed something strange with the Bible particularly the Old Testament. Adam and Eve had three children, Cain, Abel, and I forgot the third one's name which is not good on my part, but after Cain killed his brother and was exiled, it said he left with his wife.... The bible never talks about how she was born
 
My Referring to that guy as COC was just the denomination he represented. He was clearly not a fair representation of the denomination as a whole.

My children did attend a COC school in Chattanooga by the name of Boyd Buchanan. The education and extracurricular activities were top notch. I do not regret it at all. I was able to have honest conversations with my children as we went about the differences it the denomination beliefs and ours. I’ve always taught them that your beliefs don’t have to align with anyone else as you are only responsible for yourself at the judgment. It makes it easy to discuss things that way.
Have your beliefs and hold the dear while having respect for others and allowing them to do the same

This is what we told our kids. Its OK to believe differently from me/us. Just make sure you know why you believe the things you do. Makes for great discussions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Orangeslice13
Slice believes……

There is the G-d of A,I,and J. And the Messiah whom He sent.
The only begotten of G-d. I do not believe in a Trinity. The Holy sprit is simply the working of G-d the father.
An analogy I use is if G-d is fire the Yeshua would be an ember of the fire. The unique and only ember. The very DNA of the father but not the father. All is given to him by the father. He’s our advocate and kindsmen redeemer before G-d at our judgement.


The law is both a blessing and can be a curse. The law is still the definition of sin. Adherence to the law doesn’t save you but it does please G-d. Psalms 119 is a picture of what that looks like.

I believe Paul, like Yeshua was a teacher of the law. Show me any teachings of either and I’ll show you what he’s teaching in Torah

I reject Hebrews as scripture. It wasn’t written by Paul or any of the 12. It contains too may errors to be scripture.

I very much enjoy these conversations as we are called to refine our faith like silver. The way to do that is to heat it up and beat the impurities off of it.

See I misremembered. Sorry. Thats why I didnt make that statement from a place of confidence. I thought you rejected some of the books attributed to Paul (there are so many). Thanks for clearing that up. I agree. Everything else is pretty much where I thought you were. I really like M. J. Keeping the Law as best you can is cool. I have nearly quit eating pork. It just doesn't appeal to me like it used to. Bacon smells so good though
 

Advertisement



Back
Top