Pats vs Jets

[volfanjustin]

My intention was not to say that Brady is the greatest of all-time, just that he will be considered great by his Super Bowl victories, if nothing else. He should go down with his name in the same conversation with the likes of Aikman and Bradshaw. Are there other guys on either list that I would take over Brady, sure, but that wasn't my argument.

I really like the Aikman comparison. Had great talent around him but we just a really good player himself, not great.

 

[orangetanker11]

It would rightfully earn him the rep of being good in the clutch. Hard to argue with it.

Agree 100%

 

[TrueOrange]

Pats, not likely. Colts, no way in hell.

agree; at least not with the recent set ups the teams have

 

[TrueOrange]

My intention was not to say that Brady is the greatest of all-time, just that he will be considered great by his Super Bowl victories, if nothing else. He should go down with his name in the same conversation with the likes of Aikman and Bradshaw. Are there other guys on either list that I would take over Brady, sure, but that wasn't my argument.

that's a pretty good comparison

 

[emainvol]

yes he's on the list of QB's who won the SB multiple times. However if we're picking there are some on the first list I take over the second

If Steve Young didn't have to compete with the 90s Cowboys, he probably wins at least 3 as a starter. I would take him over almost all those guys
Posted via VolNation Mobile

 

[kptvol]

It would rightfully earn him the rep of being good in the clutch. Hard to argue with it.

He was horrific in his first Super Bowl win. Pretty good in the second, but still probably second best QB performance of the day.

 

[kptvol]

I think Manning and Brady were in the same boat this year. I wonder if either one of those teams makes the playoffs without their respective QBs. I don't think it is likely to be honest.

Don't think Brady had to deal with the number of injuries Manning did.