I will say this about Kiffin.
I didn't like the guy from the word go. He wasn't a Tennessee guy, he was a west coast USC guy. That's enough not to like him. Further he was/is about as mature as a 15 year old. He acts like a kid.
That said, during his year here if you saw something one week that wasn't working it would be fixed by the next week. The team progressed as the year moved on and got better. Jonathan Crompton wasn't worth 2 hoots till Kiffin's crew got ahold of him. Now, I'm not sure if Monte was running the show and doing the fixing, or Ed Ogeron, or who it was.
When Dooley came here 3 12 men on the field penalties killed us the first year. I guarantee under Kiffin if we'd have lost a game from the 1st one, the next week there would have been a dozen 3rd stringers and 4 assistant coaches tasked with counting people from the sideline to make damn sure that didn't happen again.
For all his faults and his smart California mouth, I give Kiffin credit.
I even think as bad as Dooley was he was better than Butch. Butch's teams played their best ball the 1st game of the season and grew no more as players through the season which is why his teams lost to the doormats 3 times. A good coach can take a mediocre player and get him going by midway through the season. Butch took good players and made them worse as the season wore on.