Might want to to tap the brakes... Sounds like nothing has been decided yet.
Normally, in a situation such as this, I would say this is up to the coach and the coach alone. When you leave such decisions to players, you are relegating your authority, which is a sign of weakness.
But seeing as how CJP was not a part of last years team that Jennings allegedly quit on, let those who know him best decide his fate.