Of Tennesse quarterbacks who have been starters in the past, Tee Martin and Heath Shuler have the physical structure best suited to withstand the kind of punishment that SEC defenses dispense on a weekly basis. Previous contributors have already cited serious injuries sustained by Brent Schaffer, Jerry Colquitt, Todd Helton and Tony Robinson. Go back and watch the Kenny Chesney-directed special about Condredge Holloway if you want a first-hand account of the punishment that the Artful Dodger was regularly taking. Fast forward to James Franklin, the Missouri QB, who racked up ca. 3,800 yds. total offense last year, in the Big 12, almost 1,000 yds. on the ground. This year? He has missed nearly half the season, due to knee and shoulder injuries. Still not convinced?
Look at the table below (excerpted from
http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/stats/football_records/2012/fbs.pdf ) of the leading single-season rushing performances by quarterbacks. Do you notice a pattern? With the exception of Cam Newton, none of them played for an SEC team. None of these quarterbacks played weekly against the caliber of competition, not to mention the physical style of defense which has, for so long, typified SEC football.
Player, Team Year G Carries Yards TD Yds/G
Denard Robinson, Michigan ..................... 2010 13 256 *1,702 14 130.9
Beau Morgan, Air Force ............................... 1996 11 225 1,494 18 *135.8
Cam Newton, Auburn .................................. 2010 14 264 1,473 20 105.2
Stacey Robinson, Northern Ill. ................. 1989 11 223 1,443 19 131.2
Joe Webb, UAB ................................................ 2009 12 227 1,427 11 118.9
Jammal Lord, Nebraska ............................... 2002 14 251 1,412 8 100.9
Brad Smith, Missouri ..................................... 2003 13 212 1,406 18 108.2
Chandler Harnish, Northern Ill. ............... 2011 14 194 1,379 11 98.5
Chris McCoy, Navy ......................................... 1997 11 246 1,370 20 124.5
Julian Edelman, Kent St. .............................. 2008 12 215 1,370 13 114.2
Patrick White, West Virginia ....................... 2007 13 197 1,335 14 102.7
Dee Dowis, Air Force .................................... 1987 12 194 1,315 10 109.6
Brian Mitchell, La.-Lafayette ...................... 1989 11 237 1,311 19 119.2
Brad Smith, Missouri ..................................... 2005 12 229 1,301 16 108.4
Fred Solomon, Tampa .................................. 1974 11 193 1,300 19 118.2
Dee Dowis, Air Force .................................... 1989 12 172 1,286 18 107.2
Beau Morgan, Air Force ............................... 1995 12 229 1,285 19 107.1
Antwaan Randle El, Indiana ...................... 2000 11 218 1,270 13 115.5
Stacey Robinson, Northern Ill. ................. 1990 11 193 1,238 19 112.5
Chance Harridge, Air Force ........................ 2002 13 252 1,229 23 94.5
Chris McCoy, Navy ......................................... 1996 11 268 1,228 16 111.6
Pat White, West Virginia ............................... 2006 12 165 1,219 18 101.6
Keith Boyea, Air Force .................................. 2001 12 230 1,216 18 101.3
Colin Kaepernick, Nevada .......................... 2010 14 173 1,206 20 86.1
Ricky Dobbs, Navy ......................................... 2009 13 315 1,203 *27 92.5