Admittedly, I haven't gone back and read every post in this thread. I think I can imagine it's contents. However, what did Kiffin do to dump a "10 gallon can of gasoline" on it? If he stayed, I think he would have won big here. NCAA stuff was just minor secondary stuff. The person that dumped the gas on it was Hamilton. Had he just named Kippy the Interim HC for 2010 and run an actual, legitimate search at the end of the 2010 season, we would be in a much better spot, in my opinion. Rushing to hire Dooley was the big blunder, not Kiffin.
As to your original point about running Boyd and Petty off, I do see your point. At that time, nobody knew he would bolt after a year. I don't blame him for not taking them. If he would have stayed, could you imagine the offense he would have had with Bray slinging it all over the place? In hindsight, it was a bad deal. I think looking back now everybody would have wanted things done differently. If we would have known what we know now, I would have wanted Fulmer to stay (I didn't disagree with the decision to let him go at the time). He would have had Boyd at QB, and who knows what would have happened. As it stands, I was pumped up about having Kiffin and still wish he would have stayed.
Water under the bridge. Go Vols...Go Coach JH!!!