Explain Your Logic Please

#1

Dagreek1998

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2005
Messages
381
Likes
22
#1
I really struggle to understand the cool-aid drinkers sometimes. When I look at whats going on at Ole Miss and Miss St., I just have to wonder.

If you look at Ole Miss, Freeze inherits a program that went 24-26 in the four years before him and a roster filled with players representing the #19, #18, #18, #29 ranked classes. Thats no top 5, no top 10, no top 15 classes and and an overall average of #21. Not horrible, but far from great. In his first year, he finishes with a winning record and a bowl bid. His second year, he wins 8 games and another bowl bid. All awhile doing this in the SEC West, a heck of a lot tougher path than the SEC East. Now in his third year, he has slayed the giant and sits ranked in the top 5 with a firm grasp on the SEC championship and maybe even a national championship.

If you look at Miss. St., Mullen inherits a program that went 18-30 in the four years before him and a roster filled with players representing the #44, #39, #46, #33 ranked classes. Not a single top 25 class and an overall average of #41. Since then, he has went 41-28 with 4 straight bowl bids.Again, all awhile doing this in the SEC West. Now, Mullens has Miss St. ranked in the top 5 and considered a major factor in the national title hunt.

Now, look at Butch Jones. Yes, he inherited a team that went 23-27 in the four years before. But that is no worse than Freeze and alot better than Mullens. Now as for talent level, Butch inherited a roster comprised of the #17, #13, #9, #10 ranked classes. No, not everyone in those classes stayed, but I have a heard time believing that the class ended up being worse than Freeze and there is no way it was worse than what Mullens. Now, here we are with Butchs second year and could end up with another losing season. All awhile the crys of a young roster can be heard from every cool-aid drinker on this board.

To that I simply ask:

1) Is it easier to turn a team around in the SEC West?
2) Is it easier to turn Ole Miss or Miss St. around?
3) Has the rules changed and we can keep players for an extra 2 to 3 years, cause I can hear it next year? Offense is bad because no QB, Defense is bad because no AJ. The year after than, it will be QB not ready just yet and replacing most of the OL and secondary.
4) Why was it ok to want Fulmer gone for his loyalty with Sanders but not Butch with his loyalty for Bajakana? I mean you run the read option 73 times an Worley has kept it twice. If you don't block the guy on the end, he is going to make the tackle. At least fake a backside slant or something. And the passing on short yardage or the first and goal at Oklahoma, after we established the run game, and we through a pick 6.

I am not saying Butch should be fired, but he had better make some adjustments to his staff including the OL coach. I mean, coleman starting in place of Blair?? Really, neither of them may be able to block but at least the DL has farther to go to get around Blair.

Ok, Sunshine Sally, pipe back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 10 people
#4
#4
Have you considered that Freeze and Mullen are better head coaches?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 15 people
#6
#6
Yeah, there will always be an excuse and folks here will always find one to argue that our mediocrity is the best we can expect.

No one wants to acknowledge that the successful coaches in this league would have excuses if they failed too, but they don't have to use them, because they actually go out and regularly exceed expectations and raise them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people
#7
#7
Seriously. Please stop with the same threads over and over. I've read this same thing at least 5 times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 7 people
#10
#10
Seriously. Please stop with the same threads over and over. I've read this same thing at least 5 times.

And yet someone posts the same exact "UT's rebuild is that same as Kansas State's" excuse thread twice on here today, and no one complains.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#11
#11
Have you considered that Freeze and Mullen are better head coaches?

Have you considered not posting again? CBJ has won more conference championships as a head coach than both of them combined. Their combined number being ONE.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people
#12
#12
Have you considered that Mullen has been at MSU six years and Freeze at Miss for three?

To be fair, i was giving OP a logical reason which might satisfy him for the difference.

I hate losing but i am still pro Butch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#13
#13
Have you considered not posting again? CBJ has won more conference championships as a head coach than both of them combined. Their combined number being ZERO.

Easy pratt. I'm not attacking Butch. He coaches the team i love.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#14
#14
Have you considered that Mullen has been at MSU six years and Freeze at Miss for three?

Freeze's turn around at ole miss has been remarkable, I think it will soon be rivaled by that of Stoops at UK. Just hope we can gain ground soon, eventually the recruiting is going to dry up without on field results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#16
#16
We play the most freshman of any team in college football. Thats not an opinion, there is no debating it.

A FRESHMAN QB, that had 2 career passes, lead a fourth quarter comeback against us at home. Now if Peterman, who has been on campus and under our current coaches for the last two years, cant lead us to a first down, I think that speaks volumes.

This isnt the NFL and there arent any 10 year vets. Before when we lost, we said the other team was just better. Well guess what, we just lost a game where we were the better team.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5 people
#17
#17
How about we review this staff's performance in late November before we start the inevitable "fahr Bjakakadjkfkndcnc!" "Fahrrr Maahoonnnyy!"

untitled.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#20
#20
Have you considered not posting again? CBJ has won more conference championships as a head coach than both of them combined. Their combined number being ZERO.

And Bielema won more BCS games than Butch. Was he the better hire?

The only thing that matters is what Butch does at UT and what Freeze and Mullen are doing at their schools. No one cares about what happened in the minor leagues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#21
#21
Have you considered that Mullen has been at MSU six years and Freeze at Miss for three?

And neither of them were as depleted at OL as we are right now. Our OL is the only thing between us being 2-3 right now vs 4-1.

I think it's difficult to compare the situations. I don't think we know what "level" of coach Butch is for at least two more seasons imo.

Every situation is different and has its own nuances and challenges. I think our challenges with roster right now are worse than either of them inherited.

Personally we have overachieved what I expected pre-season without returning a starter on either line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 9 people
#22
#22
Didn't ole mess pull in a top class two years ago? Or they got two of the top WR and DE?

Mullen has a bad ass QB that just breeds confidence.

Logic: 22 freshmen- guys making big showings like Kelly, Barnett, Malone, Hurd, Robertson... Special teams- Berrys, Bates before his injury, Gaulden and more!

Butch has a top class coming in next year including the #1 defensive player in the country.

You are watching him rebuild a program torched by previous coaches.

I'm in it for the long haul! Go Vols!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 8 people
#23
#23
He forgets that Mullen was on the hot seat at the begining of this year. Freeze is a very good coach, good for them.

That being said.... The season isn't over yet and Just like every other coach, Butch will be judged off of what he does in his third year. Period. Get over yourself. Go away. Do whatever it is you want to do.

4) That was stupid of anyone to want those things done. However, a good portion of our fans want things done now without having to grind through the crap that comes along with it. A big portion of our fans were spoiled by the late 90's and early 00's, to realize that even mighty Tennessee has had it's struggles just like EVERY OTHER FOOTBALL PROGRAM.

Calling for someone to get fired right now is just stupid. I can't say it enough. It's stupid. So with that being said....:shaking2:
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
#24
#24
And yet someone posts the same exact "UT's rebuild is that same as Kansas State's" excuse thread twice on here today, and no one complains.

I didn't complain when I saw this one the 2nd time either. I'm complaining now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#25
#25
cash-money.jpg
Freeze's turn around at ole miss has been remarkable, I think it will soon be rivaled by that of Stoops at UK. Just hope we can gain ground soon, eventually the recruiting is going to dry up without on field results.

is the reason for Ole Miss turnaround
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Advertisement



Back
Top