Could Chaney make JG another Crompton?

#1

OrangeBeachVol

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2019
Messages
4,276
Likes
9,272
#1
If you remember back in Kilffin's yr, Crompton was just like JG right now but he and Chaney stuck with him and all of a sudden the light came on for him and they upset UGA and went to a winning season and a bowl game. This is not a JG support thread just looking for some kind of hope at QB with a similar situation. With the 2 backup QB's not any better than JG right now seems changing QB's is just changing QB's with no better results.

I get the argument that the season is a dumpster fire anyway so go with the future. But is Maurer the future?
 
#6
#6
Chaney made Nathan Peterman get drafted, roll that around in your head for a minute. JG has done nothing but regress since we played Missouri last season. He’s a third year starter that can’t complete easy passes half the time and makes terrible decisions with the football. Only way he can be helped is by benching his ass.
 
#7
#7
If you are truly remembering that 2019 season, you will remember that Crompton had five touchdown passes in the season opener against Western Kentucky. It’s not like it took half the season for the light to come on.

Right, but Kiffin did have to revamp play calling after the first 3-4 games going into the UGA game.

The playcalling from UGA until end of the season was drastically different from the first 4 games with Crompton.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Remy
#9
#9
JG lacks Football knowledge

He has talent, just not the ability to use it. It's like the kid that does great on everything except tests. His brain goes into vapor lock when the pressure is on
Idk. Pressure seems to make him better; it’s when the protection is good when he really struggles. Maybe we should call plays that involve the running back slapping the absolute piss out of him after a few seconds?
 
  • Like
Reactions: TOUCHDOWN!!TN
#12
#12
I think it's up to Chaney to decide. He's a brilliant OC, QB and OL coach. He's getting paid $1.6M. I trust that he'll make the right decision in advising Pruitt which QB he should invest most of his time in.

Btw, I'm not supporting JG. I like the leadership, fire, moxy and mobility Maurer shows but ultimately I trust the coaches to make the right decision. After all it's their careers at TN that are at stake.
 
#15
#15
If you remember back in Kilffin's yr, Crompton was just like JG right now but he and Chaney stuck with him and all of a sudden the light came on for him and they upset UGA and went to a winning season and a bowl game. This is not a JG support thread just looking for some kind of hope at QB with a similar situation. With the 2 backup QB's not any better than JG right now seems changing QB's is just changing QB's with no better results.

I get the argument that the season is a dumpster fire anyway so go with the future. But is Maurer the future?


I think JG is mentally shot and not salvagable at this point. Is Maurer the future? Maybe not in the long term, but I think he's our best option for the remainder of this season. I think the QB change needs to happen today and give Maurer two weeks of reps with the 1's. I don't think we win another game this year with JG at QB.
 
#17
#17
If you remember back in Kilffin's yr, Crompton was just like JG right now but he and Chaney stuck with him and all of a sudden the light came on for him and they upset UGA and went to a winning season and a bowl game. This is not a JG support thread just looking for some kind of hope at QB with a similar situation. With the 2 backup QB's not any better than JG right now seems changing QB's is just changing QB's with no better results.

I get the argument that the season is a dumpster fire anyway so go with the future. But is Maurer the future?
I think that's precisely what they hoped to do. It did not work. Attempts to push JG just a little more have resulted in him getting much worse.

Whether confidence or mental "talent", there is simply something that prevents him from being decisive and making plays. It is sad. He has a great arm. He's tough. He seems to work hard. The game just doesn't seem to slow down for him.
 
#18
#18
If you remember back in Kilffin's yr, Crompton was just like JG right now but he and Chaney stuck with him and all of a sudden the light came on for him and they upset UGA and went to a winning season and a bowl game. This is not a JG support thread just looking for some kind of hope at QB with a similar situation. With the 2 backup QB's not any better than JG right now seems changing QB's is just changing QB's with no better results.

I get the argument that the season is a dumpster fire anyway so go with the future. But is Maurer the future?

I seem to remember Comp being cocky, that helped. JG? not the type of guy Comp was, he just seems to be a "glass half full" type personality. Not a guy that "the light bulb will come for" just goes against his whole being.
 
#20
#20
If you remember back in Kilffin's yr, Crompton was just like JG right now but he and Chaney stuck with him and all of a sudden the light came on for him and they upset UGA and went to a winning season and a bowl game. This is not a JG support thread just looking for some kind of hope at QB with a similar situation. With the 2 backup QB's not any better than JG right now seems changing QB's is just changing QB's with no better results.

I get the argument that the season is a dumpster fire anyway so go with the future. But is Maurer the future?
Tennessee was favored in that game. And the lights didn't come on for Crompton, they rolled him out so he had to only read half of the field. Difference is Crompton was faster and had a higher football IQ than JG. JG survived in High School with a strong arm but now that the game requires mental make up as well, he's just not getting it. He has the football IQ of a Junior in High School.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lifeVol
#22
#22
Right, but Kiffin did have to revamp play calling after the first 3-4 games going into the UGA game.

The playcalling from UGA until end of the season was drastically different from the first 4 games with Crompton.

Believe it or not, Kif had some players with experience AND talent. This staff has little upperclassmen talent and little experience for youngsters. If Kif was in the position this staff faces, he would do no better.
 
#23
#23
i don't think anyone could foretell the magnitude of JG"s regression coming into this year. The pounding he took game after game last year robbed him of whatever ability he had to stand in the pocket and go through his progressions in the time he has to do it. It was already not his strong suit to begin with and now he is like a rabbit ready to bail from the second he gets the ball. But he is too slow to run and buy time or run on his own. How he ever was listed as dual threat is mystifying. He will look to first option and if it isn't immediately available,he goes to check down receiver, no matter whether he is covered or what the down and distance is. Add into that his inability to accurately hit open receivers when he does have time leaves us with essentially no offensive option. We can go with pass plays tht have little possibility of good outcome or run off tackle over and over like BYU game.
At this point, we might win a few more games this year or not. It doesn't really matter. I think most people on here are just shocked at the reality of where we are. I don't recall any 1 or 2 win predictions before this year started, even from the most negative posters. We have to start looking to next year. Even if Bailey follows through and signs, what are the chances a true freshman is going to be ready to play from day 1? The best thing we can do now is start getting Maurer and Shrout as much real game practice as we can before next year. Between them and Hill, it should still be a big improvement over where we are now. There are no mistakes Maurer or Shrout can make that will turn this season into anything other than what it already has become. We just need to man up and take our beatdowns and start preparing for next year.
Once you accept the reality of where we are and stop the pie in the sky predictions of beating Florida and Georgia or maybe anybody else this year, it is a lot easier to look long range to our return to competitive football.
 
#24
#24
Believe it or not, Kif had some players with experience AND talent. This staff has little upperclassmen talent and little experience for youngsters. If Kif was in the position this staff faces, he would do no better.
You do remember the Sullins twins, right? Not to mention he took Aaron Douglas as TE and turned him into a Tackle for his freshman year. Pruitt has more to work with, especially on the OL
 
  • Like
Reactions: Remy
#25
#25
You do remember the Sullins twins, right? Not to mention he took Aaron Douglas as TE and turned him into a Tackle for his freshman year. Pruitt has more to work with, especially on the OL
"yea, maybe this year, but "o-line better than Kif" Don't think so, not after you get past the younguns.
 
Advertisement



Back
Top