More accurately, our Checker Neyland winning percentage is low (20%) because (a) we've been in a slump since it was invented and (b) we've checkered the games against some very good opponents most of those years.
Florida...#5 Oklahoma...#14 Florida...#2 Georgia...#11 Ole Miss
Let's break that down:
1. The 2014 Florida Gators weren't all that good. In their 2nd game of the season, it took them 3 overtimes to finally beat Kentucky, and in week 3 they lost to Bama something like 40-20. BUT we were even less far along. Butch's second season, still trying to build something, anything, out of the Dooley mess. It wasn't enough, though the game was close. We lost 10-9.
2. The 2015 Oklahoma Sooners were the #5 team in the country. We almost beat them in a checkered Neyland stadium. Came down to overtime in a thrilling game.
3. The 2016 season saw our first checkered Neyland victory, a 38-28 stomp-down of the Gators. And a decent Gators team, too, they ended the year ranked #14 in the land.
4. Ending the early run of this new tradition, in 2017 we checkered the stadium against the eventual #2, Georgia.
5. Then, after a three year break from checkering the stadium (we never did it with Pruitt as head coach, that's one thing he didn't tarnish), we had a real opportunity in Josh Heupel's first year. We checkered against Ole Miss. Everyone knows how that turned out: tie. With the referees giving the tie-breaker to Ole Miss. Who ended the season the #11 team in the country.
So let's don't put bad juju on Checker Neyland. It's an awesome new tradition. We just asked it to lift some really heavy weights in its infancy.
As it matures, I expect it to be a victory formation for Tennessee fandom.
Go Vols!