Nobody should defend the "passing" game. It is atrocious. But there are a lot of parts in the passing game. And truthfully the word "talent" you use at the end is purely subjective. Some of us look at it this way: we evaluate these aspects of the passing game and if all of the other aspects get good grades then no doubt it's on the position coach:
OLine Production
QB pass accuracy
Play Calling
WR talent level
If I thought all of those aspects were conducive to producing great stats in the passing game then only the WR coach to blame. But I not to ignore our deficiencies over the past few years in those areas.
But hey, you could be right and moving on from Coach Z may be the right move. I just want to see this year play out (especially if we start taking more shots like I've been hearing we will do) before I take such a strong stance regarding termination of a coach.
Am I being unreasonable?
1. Not unreasonable at all, very well thought out. I agree there are multiple factors involved in why or why not a passing game doesn't produce. That's always true for every team and certainly applies here. You listed the factors, I agree there.
2. I'll disagree with you about our talent at WR being a subjective proposition. It's not subjective to say that having a bunch of universally highly rated, big 6'3-6'4, 200-215, fast and über athletic guys running around at WR means that we're there. I don't think anybody has said our group this year and indeed the last years wasn't talented. However, a whole lot of people have said they weren't productive and that they weren't being properly developed and I think the evidence bears those two points out in spades.
3. I'm not one to get on here and say "I've watched all the tape, I'm the expert here, Azzani sucks and he's gotta go". To the contrary, what I've done is watch the games and, from a layman fan's perspective, seen what everybody else has seen....our WRs don't produce, don't get open, don't make plays that so many other SEC WRs do who are either equally or less talented by most peoples' accounts.
And then I've listened to credible sources/experts who give their reasoning for why our WRs haven't produced.....guys like Jayson Swain, Joey Kent and even Erik Ainge. And then I hear Swain say he's even heard from other former Vol WRs such as Cedric Wilson pretty much saying wtf is going on with how our WRs are being coached? What's up with that ridiculous stance? Why are they trying to rotate so many guys as opposed to playing their best guys a majority of the time? Azzani is coaching too many details, too much minutae and its tying up the guys mentally and not allowing them to play freely to the level of their abilities....etc, etc.
4. We now have 3 years worth of sample size for Azzani. He got a pass his first year because he didn't have much to work with, no problem. Then the second year, when North took a step back and the general WR play wasn't exactly sterling, eyebrows were raised and people started questioning him. And then last year he gets named passing game coordinator, with very good talent on the edges and a stable QB situation (Dobbs came into last season with 7-8 starts under his belt in his 3rd year in the system) ..... and the passing game as a whole took a significant step backward.
At the end of the day, Azzani's job is to help bring in top talent...he and Butch have done that. But even more importantly, his job is develop his players and have them be productive receivers at least commensurate to their talent levels....and surely we can agree that hasnt happened. When next year's NFL draft rolls around, it'll very likely signify the 4th straight year that Azzani hasn't put a WR in the league from "Wide Receiver U". At some point, he simply has to be held accountable.
5. I'll end with this......
Top 2015 SEC WR tandems per team-
Bama- 152 catches, 1,745 yds, 11 tds
UT- 69 catches, 815 yds, 5 tds
Miss St- 148 catches, 1,925 yds, 12 tds
UT- 69 catches, 815 yds, 5 tds
Texas A&M - 131 catches, 1,916 yds, 12 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
Ole Miss- 119 catches, 1,797 yds, 15 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
Kentucky- 101 catches, 1,302 yds, 5 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
Georgia- 93 catches, 1,244 yds, 7 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
Arkansas- 91 catches, 1,378 yds, 16 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
LSU- 71 catches, 1,231 yds, 9 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds
Freaking VANDY- 75 catches, 998 yds, 5 tds
UT- 69 catches, 814 yds, 5 tds