I did a more complicated formula for each...
number of total pages for each in the recruiting forum - number of pages not relevant to them in their topic threads. Then took the number of pages of negative posts/number of pages of relevant posts.
for Evans there is 215 total pages-212 pages of random nonsense which gives me 3 pages of relevant posts of which 2 are negative where people who don’t know him label him a trouble maker for 33% chance
For Beckwith there is 91 pages total and 2 total pages of relevant posts with 1.5 positive so a 75% chance.
And Wideman Is 50%.