RetroVol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2025
- Messages
- 1,287
- Likes
- 4,900
None of these kids have ever played in two minute spurts, nor been asked to press and trap bigger, stronger more talented players relentlessly even when it's not working. I don't believe a practice environment can simulate any of that accurately.
@glv98, always appreciate your views, and even more when they challenge my own (as they often do). One of the few ways to actually confront cofirmation bias is to really converse with someone who has deeply held beliefs the opposite of one's own.
That said, I'm going to dig a little into these two sentences
I suspect this is almost 100% accurate. If any had played in any system similar to Kim's, we'd have heard about it. You have also often gone on to suggest that they can't be successful that way, which is countered by the fact that players have been successful in these systems, not only under Kim, but elsewhere, and by the improved performance of players under Kim's coaching.None of these kids have ever played in two minute spurts,
I'm not sure what you're saying here. That Tennessee has, under Kim, had smaller, weaker, less talented players than... the very best teams they played? The average in the SEC? Overall? I don't see that as true. And even against the best, they beat UCONN, Ohio State on their home floor, other teams that ended up above them in the SEC (KY last year, for example). And, as we all know, performed creditably against the top of the SEC in Kim's first year. Plus she won a Natty with a smaller team, turned around Marshall in one season, etc., etc. etc. So, overall, Kim's system has worked, even here, though last year's complete collapse at year end is still something we can argue about as far as causes, but without much data to go on.been asked to press and trap bigger, stronger more talented players relentlessly even when it's not working.
Sure it can, though whether Kim chooses to do so I don't know. "Bigger, stronger, more talented players" = men's practice squad. If they want such competition and are willing to cut them loose, there it is. The men's team can't practice against teams that are as good as they face on the floor, the women can. Might not be a good idea. But they can.I don't believe a practice environment can simulate any of that accurately.
They could also recreate game conditions. In fact, one of the most successful men's DII coaches ever did just that. Jim Crutchfield built West Liberty into a Division II powerhouse before moving to Nova Southeastern in Florida in 2017 and doing it again.
Watch an interview with him here: The Basketball Podcast: EP291 with Jim Crutchfield—Inside the Mind, from Basketball Immersion.
- 3:49—Practice philosophy: They spend much of practice playing live basketball; most drills serve as warm-ups.
- 5:08—Brief teaching interruptions: He freezes players in position, teaches from the situation, and expects everyone to listen.
- 5:52–6:26—The precise detail you remembered: He says the interruptions generally last five to fifteen seconds, then they immediately resume playing.
