Man im not trying to be one of those JG bashers bc i really respect that kids toughness but i will call it like i see it. U are basing your opinion off 1 or 2 games. He may very well start games 1 and 2 but that doesnt mean he will start the entire year so that makes him a place holder. That Bama comparison was not a good one. Bama did win with mediocre QB's but their roster wasnt just talented it was elite at every single position. They sending 8-10 guys to the NFL every year. They got 5 star recruits waiting 2-3 years to play. When did we ever finish with 5 straight #1 recruiting classes?? NEVER so it aint the same situation. We dnt need Joe Montana at Qb we just need someone who won't make freshman mistakes in their 3rd year. U are right that u dnt need a stud Qb to have success but u do need a competent one. Tee Martin wasnt some super prolific passer but he also wasnt going to give the game away and made the plays that counted. JG still being on campus doesnt mean squat especially when coach has publicly stated its a competition. It dnt matter what he did after the KY game bc the other qbs were either hurt or weren't even on the roster yet so who else was supposed to take the snaps. Coach is playing his hand exactly like he is supposed to when u are not sold on the other guys. I think we are all more confident in JG then BM or Shrout. He wins that by default. We also dnt wanna throw HB to the wolves if we dnt have too. We know Holiday is not ready and we are not sure whats going on with Hill so why not bring in a guy who could push JG. It just sounds to me like u would rather settle with what u have rather then turn over every single stone to be sure.
