Recent content by S.C. OrangeMan

Cutcliffe without a doubt. Maybe Chavis for second. Worst? Sunseri. I still have nightmares about "3rd and Sunseri".

If he wins they will simply give him two more years starting then.

If they do, they'll simply lose in court when the inevitable lawsuits are filed.

The service academy athletes get their military pay but cannot have NIL deals.

Relative value and supply vs demand.. An elite quarterback is a fairly rare commodity. There are numerous good offensive kinemen.

You said it yourself. You basically said that athletes should be treated the same as other students, except when they weren't. Thosevtwo things are mutually exclusive

He didn't lose the case. He simply didn't get the injunction that would have allowed him to play the test of this season. He can still pursue the case in either Alabama state court or a federal court.

Any individual school can choose to not take any incoming transfers. That's how you take a playoff team to mediocrity in one season. Clemson and Stanford are examples. No exceptions for athletes? Illegal. Please review the Ohio vs NCAA case and get back to me.

Easy. If the policy violates federal law and/or court rulings, they would be liable.

That would just make the schools individually liable for getting sued for violating federal law. No school administrators have yet been that stupid. It would also put those schools at a competitive disadvantage against schools that had no such policy. If a conference did it, they would have...

The NCAA rules are based on their trying to maintain their "amateurism" sham that has been repudiated by the courts.

They refuse to accept reality. They don't do anything to accept the current reality that a court doesn't force them to do.

False equivalence. The NCAA is not a government and they are not above the law. The NCAA is nothing like any government.

Why? It's not 1973 any more.

Not at all. The NCAA has no authority outside of their members institutions.