It was actually $3675 after looking. Still a great value.
I found it through a Facebook group called Eluethera Direct Vacation Rentals by Owner.
Here's a link...
Knoxville - Charlotte - N Eleuthera.
We flew into North Eleuthera. It was quite a bit less than flying to Governor's Harbour. A little bit of a drive but didn't bother us.
4 couples go in and it's about $800/couple.
4 bedrooms.
2 Couples with kids.could do it for $1600 per family.
Obviously it gets expensive with flights.