Recent content by Im_Vol_In

I thought on the personal foul call the ref said "unnecessary roughness" on number 50. Did not have DVR so can't be sure.

Yes. Danielson said something about how they were taking their time and I thought they didn't take very long at all.

In fact, the view of the replay is partially blocked by the head of the official who made the initial call and had a better view of the play than anyone (including the replay official).

oops, didn't mean to multi-quote

I kept asking "how do they not have another angle?" From seeing the CBS angle, I thought it was probably not a touchdown, but was definitely inconclusive. You just could not even see his left hand to tell what was going on. It is just so frustrating to see people (announcers, vol fans, uga...

I saw a fumble also. But at what point? If there was definitive evidence, then one should be able to express arguments supporting that point (i.e. "the ball was spinning in his hand before he crossed the goal line" or "the ball left his hand altogether before crossing the goal line" or "the...

I myself watched it a thousand times. I would think we could both agree that if we both watched it a thousand times, then there is something very unclear about whether or not it was a touchdown, and to overturn the ruling on the field, there should exist definitive evidence.

If it was so clear, why did you have to watch it a thousand times?

I would love to hear what compelled the replay official to overturn the call. Unfortunately, to my knowledge, he doesn't post on Vol Nation. I was asking you, as someone who agrees with the replay official, to perhaps offer some reasons behind your opinion that there is definitive proof...

Call on the field was touchdown. You say that call should have been overturned. You must prove that it was not a touchdown

Prove it.

And in this case it isn't possession that must be proved. It must be proved that he did not have possession.

Does having the tip of the ball in you palm and touching it with four fingers and not having the ball move within your hand constitute control?

Thanks for the subtle personal attack, but can you dispute the facts I presented in any way that might lead to a meaningful conversation?