Recruiting Football Talk VII

[knoxvol52]

In all honesty, that's the way it should be. Pick the best teams.

Injuries matter. Ignoring them undermines the credibility of their selection.

They never have picked BEST 4 teams consistently.....
Who here believes Cincinnati was one of the 4 best teams a few years ago...

Herbstreit even said they usually select 4 most deserving ....

 

[drvenner]

Just think they’re better right now.

And I hate Texas.

And Michigan.

Wait I hate every team.

You shouldn't use your opinion here because it's subjective. The only objective point here is Texas beat Bama head to head.

 

[VolNRaleighNC]

So if Glenn gets hurt I guess they be going Wildcat ala Houston Nutt and Arkansas with McFadden and Felix Jones

 

[mr.checkerboards]

Good lord, come back to reality man.

I was discussing what will happen next year. You disagreed. Then you go off on a tangent about what you want the playoffs to be, as opposed to what is actually happening LMAO

Take a lap.

I know you were, and I was pointing out that it makes 0 sense.

 

[Vols410]

In all honesty, that's the way it should be. Pick the best teams.

Injuries matter. Ignoring them undermines the credibility of their selection.

Disagree. Pick the teams that have earned it. Gotta win football games. If you earned the spot with a dominant season and you lose a player at the end oh well. You earned the playoff ticket.

 

[Nash_Vol97]

️

 

[engineerVOL]

12 teams next season is great but it will be just for show....

Chalk will prevail 95% of time , you may get the occasional big upset...

But it will be surprising if semifinals every year aren't the top 4 seeds every year....

Just more $$$$$$ for networks ...

Anybody really believe a 12th seeded Kansas State would even smell the championship game?

It’s all window dressing.

Nobody is gonna get hot and make a run. It will be the same ole, same ole champions.

It’s basically the same bowl season setup we have now with interesting matchups, just with more implication on the front end.

 

[engineerVOL]

You shouldn't use your opinion here because it's subjective. The only objective point here is Texas beat Bama head to head.

We’ll see what the committee does. Recency bias is real but is a pretty good indicator of how teams are playing right now,

 

[StoVol]

Fiske for FSU, dang that boy is mad

 

[VolNRaleighNC]

Glenn is literally a deer in headlights

 

[knoxvol52]

Glenn is literally a deer in headlights

You noticed it also...

 

[jakez4ut]

️

 

[VolNRaleighNC]

Fiske for FSU, dang that boy is mad

We gotta get some true “dawgs” (not UGA) in the portal

 

[StoVol]

We’ll see what the committee does. Recency bias is real but is a pretty good indicator of how teams are playing right now,

Remember Bama needed a miracle to beat lowly Auburn
So recently they have shown they can stink it up
Also Milroe is about as good passing as Milton
If you can scheme to stop his running you can beat Bama

 

[Enki_Amenra]

12 teams next season is great but it will be just for show....

Chalk will prevail 95% of time , you may get the occasional big upset...

But it will be surprising if semifinals every year aren't the top 4 seeds every year....

Just more $$$$$$ for networks ...

Anybody really believe a 12th seeded Kansas State would even smell the championship game?

In some years, possibly, if they had early season injuries. I remember UT having teams that looked unbeatable at the end of the year, but lost early in the season.

 

[Jimmy Football]

Storm Duck with a big hit.

 

[jakez4ut]

Ugh.

 

[PKT_VOL]

They never have picked BEST 4 teams consistently.....
Who here believes Cincinnati was one of the 4 best teams a few years ago...

Herbstreit even said they usually select 4 most deserving ....

I understand. This is an is vs ought debate.

I'm rooting for FSU because the they typically (is) pick via deserving criteria. However, the should (ought) simply pick the best 4 teams at season's end.

 

[DawgInterloper]

In all honesty, that's the way it should be. Pick the best teams.

Injuries matter. Ignoring them undermines the credibility of their selection.

I agree. FSU was never a great team and without their QB they are not top four IMO. The committee members have said their goal is the four best, not the "most deserving". I'd go with Michigan, Washington, Texas, and Alabama. I usually pull for the SEC in the championship, but I'll go for Washington or Texas this year. Saban's won enough rings.

 

[StoVol]

We gotta get some true “dawgs” (not UGA) in the portal

Yeah he was from a directional michigan school
Heckuva player tho

 

[knoxvol52]

In some years, possibly, if they had early season injuries. I remember UT having teams that looked unbeatable at the end of the year, but lost early in the season.

Yea it can happen you're correct...

First round seeds 5-8 get a home game that's what you shoot for if you aren't a top 4 team...

 

[jakez4ut]

I understand. This is an is vs ought debate.

I'm rooting for FSU because the they typically (is) pick via deserving criteria. However, the should (ought) simply pick the best 4 teams at season's end.

 

[VolNRaleighNC]

This game is gonna be slow and sluggish and “not appealing” to the committee so even if FSU wins it may not matter in the end.

 

[Smyrna ATL Vol]

Theyve played ND, Clemson and Oregon in non conference in this run.

They also had OU scheduled and Sankey told them to buy it out. Theyve played tough games.

You really are a UGA fan.

Never seen a Vol fan want it’s two biggest rivals make a playoff.

Every post is defending them and why they should be in.

Unreal

 

[Enki_Amenra]

Should have taken the under on Iowa.

I feel like Michigan lights them up for about 30 and I think Iowa squeezes out a couple fgs or a TD.