Boston Vol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Dec 15, 2008
- Messages
- 16,762
- Likes
- 32,872
Reasonable position.Totally fine to say you don't trust Pruitt. It is true that he has never rebuilt a program. However, you don't know that he can't like I don't know if he can. I would argue that he has been apart of Alabama's rebuild under Saban as Dir of Player Development in 2007.
I can only say this that has been offered as proof for Pruitt. The best players in the two losses have been his recruits. That is visible. Pruitt has been able to go after top coaches in Tee/Chaney to upgrade the staff given the roster was coming off 4-8/5-7 seasons. It is clear that he is recruiting help on the way that seem pretty committed as well.
With that said, I think if we were to go down the Leach route, people would easily give him 2-3 season passes in the name of "recruiting players for his system" and "changing the culture" because lets face it, the culture would shift drastically from what it was under Butch and even in the AD.
I think our current staff is top notch and has a clear track record of success this decade in terms of coaching or development or recruiting, respectively.
I'd rather give Pruitt 2020 to make a big leap (8 wins minimum in regular season) when the overwhelming majority of the two deep and roster are his kids and the majority of the majority have been in his S&C for multiple years.
I just don't see the value in torching 10+ million in Pruitt/Staff buyouts plus another 5-10 million in new coach buyouts/salaries just to reset.
Well, at this rate 12 wins in 3 seasons might be an improvement or a tie with what Pruitt is capable of lol. I can honestly see 1-11 this year and the schedule is harder next year so....
I want Pruitt to succeed, but can you honestly tell me you think we should just wait and see if we go 2-10? 1-11? What about 0-12? All are very realistic possibilities if this team gives up.
I just don't see the value in torching 10+ million in Pruitt/Staff buyouts plus another 5-10 million in new coach buyouts/salaries just to reset.
You're also forgetting the "go after an entrenched coach at his alma mater and help him get a pay raise but also convince the yokels in this has-been fanbase that we are actually trying before inevitably hiring a cheap nobody that will put butts in the seats for 2-3 years before we have to hire another cheap nobody" inbetween all of that as well.
Hamilton/Hart/Currie never conducted a real search and they certainly never provided any real offers. UT has always tried to low-ball it's candidates because the admin never cared. We could have had Gary Patterson (never offered but he has said he would have taken it in 2009/2010), David Cutcliffe (offered, but fell through once he said he wanted to bring his guys... ended up getting Jones who brought his guys) and Mike Leach (never offered, he said he would have taken it in) at respective Dooley/Jones/Pruitt conjectures.
Pruitt was a panic hire by Fulmer, nothing more.
The argument for that is UT stands to lose far more than Pruitt/Staff buyouts if he tanks this year. UT will lose probably 4-5x that in lost revenue alone due to fans simply not caring enough to overspend to see Tennessee get bullied around by anyone who walks into Neyland.
Now, AGAIN, things will change if Pruitt turns the corner, but I'm pretty hesitant to throw my hat in the "I have faith" ring because:
He has no track record of being The Guy in a rebuild and his team has slipped in every definable category over the last 4/5 games.
If we start getting better QB play and can actually line up correctly half the time on D, I think we'll improve and things will normalize and we'll go back to being okay with going 4-8.
If we have not improved and continue to play like this on game 12, then the search needs to begin. I will not judge a new head coach after only 14 games. Too many "established" coaches would not be successful under those requirements.The argument for that is UT stands to lose far more than Pruitt/Staff buyouts if he tanks this year. UT will lose probably 4-5x that in lost revenue alone due to fans simply not caring enough to overspend to see Tennessee get bullied around by anyone who walks into Neyland.
Now, AGAIN, things will change if Pruitt turns the corner, but I'm pretty hesitant to throw my hat in the "I have faith" ring because:
He has no track record of being The Guy in a rebuild and his team has slipped in every definable category over the last 4/5 games.
If we start getting better QB play and can actually line up correctly half the time on D, I think we'll improve and things will normalize and we'll go back to being okay with going 4-8.
what's pruitt won? not jack ****. john majors never won the big 8 when he was at isu. fulmer never on the sec as an assistant. so leach has to win the pac 12 before he can coach here. stupid comment.
I think we all want to see Pruitt succeed because it would be the biggest F U to Butch and we would have a legit program in terms of players and system.
I do think we can win some games and try to make a run at 5-6 wins this year. We have seen Pruitt win games he shouldn't on top of the games we got blown out in.
You have to be able to say with certainty that this staff is trash and that their other coaching stops were anomalies to say there is no way Pruitt can ever succeed.
With that said, I will stick to my view on terms of Pruitt and a possible firing - I will judge him on 2020 (season 3) where he has the majority of the two deep being his kids.
Regardless of the coach, this rebuild from Butch's ceremonious fall from October 2016 was always going to be a football rebuild, roster flushing, and abrupt culture shift.
I have no reason to believe that Pruitt can't identify talent and put them in spots to contribute. We are seeing that right now.
I don't know about Saban/NeylandWhat is your point? He is supposed the be the next coming of Nick Saban or Robert Neyland. Don't see any major program even looking his way. If he was that good, why did Texas not try to lure him back. Oklahoma was desperate for a new head coach, but I can't find any evidence Mike Leach was even interviewed. (Thanks BOT for that tidbit) They knew how weak his overall coaching was so they took a powder.
So what amount of money will UT lose between now and December 2020 if we roll with Pruitt?
I'm eager to actually compare this because if we fire him after year 2, there is roughly 20 million or so additional being thrown on top of Butch's current buyout.
And in regards to your comment of "If we start getting better QB play", we can only pray. lol
Because OU already had a HOF coach (Stoops) and a Coach in waiting (Riley) that was endorsed by Stoops and Switzer (who still wields power amongst the boosters at OU). Why would they reach out to Leach?
Leach is a good coach but he did just manage 3 wins in year 3 at Washington state.He took a 2 star QB and got him into the NFL. He can develop talent, especially on offense and has done so at a school with a fraction of the resources we have. At this point, I'd take a coach that knows how to at least win 7 or 8 games a year over the worst start to the season in 30 years.
I don't know about Saban/Neyland
He's a wildcard coach who can build confidence in losers historically, the bluebloods in the conference felt too good for him
Texas and oklahoma didnt want the scandals at the time
He's not Saban but he does similar renovations, he turned a team similar to this UT crew to 11-2
You can be a Socratic debater all you want but he's a great coach and has always succeeded with less talent than Vanderbilt in recruiting. Our players quit a lot and that's what Leach changes in a program, really nothing else. He just makes them fight their 2* hearts out. I think he deserves a shot at a real program for once, but I definitely see him as risky with a prerequisite time and place for his deployment somewhere.
You'll probably nitpick some stat against him but I like him as a person and believe he could change the attitude of our players, he is a coach that changes his players mentality and gives them confidence, life coaches them, etcetc
I still want Pruitt and don't even want Leach here, I just don't see how people hate on a man who is an underdog hero who changed football schemes forever, who used his schemes to outplay 5* talent with an average of 2* on roster, unless you're a douche bag contrarian I guess