Jarrett Guarantano Performance Poll

What is your opinion of Jarrett Guarantano's performance as the STARTING QB for UT?

  • Total voters
    548
  • Poll closed .
#52
#52
Season's over, I don't care how he performed in 2018. I just care about his progress and how he performs in 2019 and beyond! :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catfishvfl
#56
#56
vol1950 said:
Who are we talking about here? lol
Click to expand...
1eqFSrO.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: 82_VOL_83
#57
#57
VolNExile said:
One day I’ll get those straight. Always seems backwards. (Assuming horrible=1 and great=5)
Click to expand...
No, you were very correct in the question, just guessed wrong how I evaluated the scale for the analysis. I have actually done some deeper analysis that I will not publish. Some might find it dry and boring. But it is right up my TBBT mindset.
 
#59
#59
volfan51128 said:
You my friend win the dumb comment award of the day!!!lol If you didn't see the O line get pushed around all season, then you have the same eyesight as Stevie Wonder. No one! Not even Manning could have played well with that line. Go back and watch the games!
Click to expand...
Oh he has an agenda and knows nothing about football. Its best to ignore his opinions.
 
#60
#60
Pride85 said:
No, you were very correct in the question, just guessed wrong how I evaluated the scale for the analysis. I have actually done some deeper analysis that I will not publish. Some might find it dry and boring. But it is right up my TBBT mindset.
Click to expand...
I used to have to prepare charts for management. It always involved a lot of pondering about "but how would management expect to see the scale go?"
BANGHEAD2.jpg
lol
 
#61
#61
VolNExile said:
I used to have to prepare charts for management. It always involved a lot of pondering about "but how would management expect to see the scale go?"
BANGHEAD2.jpg
lol
Click to expand...
That is pretty much my daily existence. Quality Engineer at an automotive supplier can be ever so much fun ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: VolNExile
#62
#62
He's behind a bad OL but he was supposed to be a top dual threat QB.:oops: He needs to pre read D's and adjust his protection. I can just recall him stepping up in the pocket twice all year both against USCe one was a beautiful hail Mary maybe had to step up to get it there and the other was a good completion. Thought he'd turned the corner but next week it was jail break and JG looking like same ole Statue of Liberty.
He is the best we have, so I guess we roll with him and hope to cut down on the 3 & outs its killing our low depth D.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Al Orange
#63
#63
Already voted and gave my analysis. I forgot to add a name I think he is equal to, not same skill sets, but equal to. Jake Bentley. I think he is about as valuable to the VOLS as Bentley is to the Gamecocks.
 
#64
#64
I selected average, but only because he "nets" to average. He shows flashes of being very good and flashes of bad. I do believe there's a lot of potential there.
 
#65
#65
SaintLouisVol said:
I selected average, but only because he "nets" to average. He shows flashes of being very good and flashes of bad. I do believe there's a lot of potential there.
Click to expand...
I agree wholeheartedly. He would be good not great with better reads or better cooperation with those reads. I see a lot of pointing and maybe recognizing blitz’s and hot mike lbs but not as much reacting like Receivers cutting routes short, rbs into the flat after a quick chip block, the squatting on a 5 yards bump, etc...
 
#66
#66
Good considering what he dealt with. I think with o-line improvement, he has a chance to improve to great. He has excellent arm strength and great accuracy in the mid range. His ability to throw across the field is also a valuable asset that we took advantage of several times. I'm looking forward to seeing the entire offense improve.
 
#67
#67
Gutsy, tough, strong arm. Doesn't read defenses.......at all. Completely ignores RB's in dump downs for positive yards. Indecisive, especially with his legs. Just move the chains, son!
 
#68
#68
This is exactly the type of discussion I hoped this poll would bring. This is a thread that had real point/ counterpoint talking points. Awesome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kbear01
#69
#69
Pride85 said:
Just wanted to post a poll as my first ever started thread. This based off a comment made I made earlier in a thread. Just want to see the sites overall opinion of JG's performance as our starting QB.
Click to expand...

Dobbs played under same coaches. Put up approx 1K more yards than JG after both having two years of practice. The only edge is that Dobbs had more real game experience by the time he took over.

That said, JG returns for his second year as a starter and behind a line he knows and that is also returning everyone with more coaching and reinforcements. He also looks like he is working hard in the off season and wants to be more than average.

For him and for us, I hope he can be. He has a long way to go to play at the next level, but then again look at Peterman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pride85
#70
#70
LargeOrange1 said:
I wish he had Dobb's wheels. JG doesn't keep the rock enough.....many times he would have had big gains or scores had he just kept the frikin ball instead of handing off for a -1 yard loss. I'm afraid we'll never compete for the East with JG.
Click to expand...
He ran very well in High School.
3 years later in college and it looks like he hasn't done a speed drill since that.

It's a damn head-scratcher!! JG was supposed to elevate the program. He was supposed to be an upgrade to Dobbs. A faster, stronger armed Dobbs...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4chrissy and vegasvolfan
#71
#71
Pride85 said:
This is the type of discussions that make it interesting to haunt this site. Please feel free to post any sort of reason you voted the way you did. It helps with this old guy's analysis of the data. Statistical analysis is the bulk of my job.
Click to expand...
I voted avg. I think he could be good but don't think he can be great.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bag12day
#73
#73
Here is my take, in the games where the O line performed best and established some kind of protection and some run game(UK,AU) he performed exceptional, on games that the team didnt play effectively, there was no pass pro and no run game(Uf,VU) from the o line, those were his worst games. Now I certainly understand that correlation doesnt equate to causation, but those that continue to ignore the other variables in a team game and blame him for the lack of team results, are either intellectually dishonest and have an agenda, or are ignorant and haven't actually looked at it in depth, they just think they can have an opinion without any evidence to back it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Volumnus 2011
#74
#74
LittleVol said:
He ran very well in High School.
3 years later in college and it looks like he hasn't done a speed drill since that.

It's a damn head-scratcher!! JG was supposed to elevate the program. He was supposed to be an upgrade to Dobbs. A faster, stronger armed Dobbs...
Click to expand...
No he wasn't, he was faster than the majority of the players around him just like most d1 level players are typically faster than their peers. Why do you hold it against him, that some reporters called him Dual threat just because he is brown( not claiming you are, just seems to be the trend with any black qb labeled as athletic or dual threat, despite evidence to the contrary), if you go back and watch his high school film, he only ran on designed runs, he wasnt a fast starter, takes him a little time to get up to full gallop, and his offense in his wasnt even a read option offense it was closer to a multiple set prostyle. Basically, all that is to say that the recruiting services are often wrong, dont get hung up on their labels, take for example josh dobbs was ranked as a pro style qb and as a dual threat by different services.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top