ChismsHeadband
*********
- Joined
- Jan 9, 2010
- Messages
- 3,760
- Likes
- 7,194
That rule is complete BS, offensive team that fumbled the ball out the back of the endzone should get the ball back on like the 20-30 or something with a loss of the down, no way should it be a touch-back for the other team. This way the team that fumbled isn't over rewarded but at the same point neither is the team on defenseI’ve always felt that was a fumble. Being as objective as possible, I can’t gripe the call, but the change of possession remains the worst rule in football by a wide margin
I say make it a 15 yd penalty with no loss of down. If you had 1st and goal from the 10, then you now have gone from nearly scoring to 1st and goal from the 25. That is plenty of punishment for the offense, and enough reward for the defense.That rule is complete BS, offensive team that fumbled the ball out the back of the endzone should get the ball back on like the 20-30 or something with a loss of the down, no way should it be a touch-back for the other team. This way the team that fumbled isn't over rewarded but at the same point neither is the team on defense
So 15 yards from the spot every time?I say make it a 15 yd penalty with no loss of down. If you had 1st and goal from the 10, then you now have gone from nearly scoring to 1st and goal from the 25. That is plenty of punishment for the offense, and enough reward for the defense.
You make a fair point, but even what effectively equates to a 75 yard penalty in the scenario you mentioned beats a turnover and giving the ball to your opponent on their 20. I could likely make an argument for either option.So 15 yards from the spot every time?
What if you just threw a 60 yard pass that was fumbled out the back of the endzone?
Just back em up to the 25 yd line and say 1st & 25?
There is no reward for fumbling out of bounds anywhere else on the field in fact if the ball rolls out without the defense recovering it that is where the spot is, so I think if you set an automatic spot for the ball to go if the penalty is called, kind of like kicking a kick-off out of bounds (ball is spotted on the 35), it makes it the most fair in regards to how other fumbles that go out of bounds are handled.
So 15 yards from the spot every time?
What if you just threw a 60 yard pass that was fumbled out the back of the endzone?
Just back em up to the 25 yd line and say 1st & 25?
There is no reward for fumbling out of bounds anywhere else on the field in fact if the ball rolls out without the defense recovering it that is where the spot is, so I think if you set an automatic spot for the ball to go if the penalty is called, kind of like kicking a kick-off out of bounds (ball is spotted on the 35), it makes it the most fair in regards to how other fumbles that go out of bounds are handled.