So Saban doesn't win with talent?
He has a lot of talent for sure. But the idea that he just signs a bunch of talent and then doesn't have to organize it, develop it, motivate it, scheme for it.....well thats just silly.
A lot of programs and coaches bring in a lot of Top 5 and Top 10 talent within range of Alabama on a regular if not annual basis....none of them have 4 titles in the last 7 seasons. For example, since 2007, Saban's first year at Bama, here are some notable teams that have several top recruiting classes according to Rivals....
LSU- 3 top 5 classes, 7 top 10s
Ohio St- 5 top 5 classes, 6 top 10s
USC- 5 top 5 classes, 8 top 10s
Texas- 5 top 5 classes, 5 top 10s
Fla St- 3 top 5 classes, 8 top 10s
Florida- 4 top 5 classes, 7 top 10s
Georgia- 1 top 5 classes, 6 top 10s
So, in that time period, 9 years, those "who's who of college football programs" have a combined 4 National Titles...same as Saban. There's a whole lot more to it than just accumulating the talent, which Saban certainly does better than anybody else....you gotta know what to do with it, which, again, Saban also does better than anybody else.
Nobody has to like Saban, I certainly don't, but everybody should give the man his due...he's earned it.