Even though you'll disagree, Reagan should be in your mix as well. You'll look at his economic policies only and call him a failure. But the man brought us out of the 70s funk as well as unifying a nation torn by post Vietnam tensions. There's something to be said for a man that wins 49 of 50 States in his reelection. Obviously the majority of people thought he was doing a good job and believed he deserved a second term.
It's not always about a single scope of a Presidency. The man knew how to compromise and work across the aisle. He knew what to say and when to say it and brought comfort to a nation time and time again. And I personally believe the
Challenger Disaster speech was one of the best speeches given by a President in modern history. Provided Peggy Noonan was behind the scenes on a great many of those, his delivery, and sincerity, was what counted.
I know I won't change your mind on this and you'll point to several things you disagree with, but Reagan was the President we needed at the time.