Last 10 Years of No. 1 Dual QB ratings

#1

ManningBerry#1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2010
Messages
3,976
Likes
400
#1
OK, first of all, I'm not advocating that Jarrett should be the starter. I was just curious of the success rate that QB's have had that have held the ranking of being No. 1 as he did in 2016.

2007 - Tyrod Taylor
2008 - Terrelle Pryor
2009 - Russell Shepard
2010 - Blake Bell
2011 - Jeff Driskel
2012 - Jameis Winston
2013 - Asiantii Woulard
2014 - Deshaun Watson
2015 - Kyler Murray
2016 - Jarrett Guarantano

Yes, there are some that didn't fair to well; however, the majority of this list made headlines. I'm hoping that our new offensive coordinator uses him to his full potential when the time is right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
#4
#4
Brent Schaeffer was the No. 7 dual threat quarterback, once upon a time. I know... who cares.

Would be interesting to have a list of all the highly rated dual threat quarterbacks Tennessee has signed over the years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#5
#5
Brent Schaeffer was the No. 7 dual threat quarterback, once upon a time. I know... who cares.

Would be interesting to have a list of all the highly rated dual threat quarterbacks Tennessee has signed over the years.

Crompton was ranked No. 3 Pro-Style QB as well.
 
#11
#11
He came a long way from the game that always comes to mind when I hear his name: the season-opener against UCLA.

Ugh, don't remind me. Those 3 INT's were a recipe for disaster. However, I loved watching Hardesty run the ball!
 
#12
#12
Out of 10 names, four are at least college success stories at QB...Taylor,Pryor,Winston and Watson. Hardly this sweeping consensus at this point. Three TBDs could sway that, but one of them being the impetus of this thread throws that science out the window.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#13
#13
He came a long way from the game that always comes to mind when I hear his name: the season-opener against UCLA.

I still remember the Hitler rant parody about that game that popped up on Youtube...it is still the best of all those parody rants.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#14
#14
Brent Schaeffer was the No. 7 dual threat quarterback, once upon a time. I know... who cares.

Would be interesting to have a list of all the highly rated dual threat quarterbacks Tennessee has signed over the years.

as rated by Rivals

Guarantano # 3
Jennings # 13
Jones # 10
Schaeffer # 7
Banks # 3
Fayton # 11
Rattay # 19
Martin # 3
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#16
#16
Asiantii Woolard has to be the biggest busts among that list .. dude was 3rd string at USF before he left that program too .. feel bad for the kid but some kids never make the transition to next level
 
#17
#17
OK, first of all, I'm not advocating that Jarrett should be the starter. I was just curious of the success rate that QB's have had that have held the ranking of being No. 1 as he did in 2016.

2007 - Tyrod Taylor
2008 - Terrelle Pryor
2009 - Russell Shepard
2010 - Blake Bell
2011 - Jeff Driskel
2012 - Jameis Winston
2013 - Asiantii Woulard
2014 - Deshaun Watson
2015 - Kyler Murray
2016 - Jarrett Guarantano

Yes, there are some that didn't fair to well; however, the majority of this list made headlines. I'm hoping that our new offensive coordinator uses him to his full potential when the time is right.

Winston was dual threat? He's a statue, a prostyle pocket passer. Interesting.
 
#19
#19
Russell Shepard was probably the most under-utilized 5* QB I've ever seen. He should sue LSU for screwing up his college career.
 
#21
#21
OK, first of all, I'm not advocating that Jarrett should be the starter. I was just curious of the success rate that QB's have had that have held the ranking of being No. 1 as he did in 2016.

2007 - Tyrod Taylor
2008 - Terrelle Pryor
2009 - Russell Shepard
2010 - Blake Bell
2011 - Jeff Driskel
2012 - Jameis Winston
2013 - Asiantii Woulard
2014 - Deshaun Watson
2015 - Kyler Murray
2016 - Jarrett Guarantano

Yes, there are some that didn't fair to well; however, the majority of this list made headlines. I'm hoping that our new offensive coordinator uses him to his full potential when the time is right.

And Pro style for comparison

2005 - Mark Sanchez
2006 - Matthew Stanford
2007 - Jimmy Clausen
2008 - Blaine Gabbert
2009 - Matt Barkley
2010 - Jake Heaps
2011 - Jeff Driskel
2012 - Gunner Kiel
2013 - Max Browne
2014 - Kyle Allen
2015 - Josh Rosen
2016 - Jacob Eason
2017 - Hunter Johnson

Analysis: Rivals either had a change in evaluation process/expertise in 2010 timeframe or the shift of the NFL game became more apparent.
 
#22
#22
Black = automatically dual threat
White = presumed statue

I rolled my eyes when I read your thread, then I saw this one:

And Pro style for comparison

2005 - Mark Sanchez
2006 - Matthew Stanford
2007 - Jimmy Clausen
2008 - Blaine Gabbert
2009 - Matt Barkley
2010 - Jake Heaps
2011 - Jeff Driskel
2012 - Gunner Kiel
2013 - Max Browne
2014 - Kyle Allen
2015 - Josh Rosen
2016 - Jacob Eason
2017 - Hunter Johnson

... not a lot of ethnic names showing up, could be something to it. I hope not for crying out loud.
 
#25
#25
So now should we list the #11 Pro-Style QB for each class, since that's where QB was listed at?
 

VN Store



Back
Top