What the "Let's give him a decade or two to clear the smoke from Raleigh's dumpster fire" crowd doesn't seem to understand is how small a window coaches have to turn programs around.
The problem with the strategy of giving a coach five or six or however many years to rebuild is that he loses credibility with the recruits who are capable of being winning SEC-caliber players.
The excitement over the hire of a new coach fades quickly if the new coach doesn't produce visible improvement fairly quickly. It fades among fans, among players, and among recruits.
When CDS showed up in summer of 2011 and said, "It's baseball time in Tennessee!" at his first press conference, he had everyone eating out of his hand. He went out with a credible sales pitch based on his 2 CWS appearances and sold the idea he would build a winner quickly. Then he immediately landed a class that will produce four or more pro players--pretty impressive considering the circumstances.
Nobody much worried that the 2012 team of inherited players didn't do well because that was a reflection on Raleigh. Then CDS cleaned house and brought in two dozen of his guys. Nobody much worried that the 2013 team didn't do well because they were all freshmen, and what could you expect? Then everybody pretended 2014 was a big step forward because we finished above .500 (thanks to the weak non-conference schedule) and made it to Hoover (thanks to them expanding the field to 12 teams) and did improve in conference and have some nice non-conference wins.
So we headed into this season with a pre-season ranking and talk of Omaha, and it turns out we're not a whole lot better than we were when this turnaround started. So now we're back to "It's still Raleigh's fault"?
Sorry, that doesn't work any more.
What is CDS going to say to the 2017 and 2018 grads this summer if Stewart and the others play out their UT careers without sniffing an NCAA regional? How relevant will his last CWS appearance, which happened when these recruits were in 3rd or 4th grade, seem to them? And what will the SEC coaches he's recruiting against say about the likelihood of Tennessee getting back to credibility?
Every year that goes by without a breakthrough makes a breakthrough harder. I think CDS should get all five years of his contract, but I also think the team needs to do better the second half of the SEC slate for us to have any basis for claiming progress. (I also think the players are capable of playing better this season, and still hope to see them prove it.)