Am I Crazy......

[Fine Vol]

My friends say they hate Tom Brady and he is overated, I think he is 2nd best QB. Am I crazy or are they?

[jakez4ut]

they are...Brady is very, very good.

between him and Manning, it's the modern day Montana/Marino debate...both are that good and worthy of such comparisons.

[milohimself]

I hate Brady and I hate the Pats... But there's no denying Tom Brady has more of the "it" factor than most any other QB in history.

[tclowers23]

Tom Brady is somewhat overrated. Some people think he's a god, but he's not. In that sense, he's overrated.

[jakez4ut]

i wouldn't call him overrated...3 rings=rated just about right. and i can't stand the guy keep in mind.

i think Manning in the technical sense of the qb position is better....but Brady is like Montana...they're winners and they just make plays.

and the guy can play...like it or not, and i don't, he can play.

[Big Orange Diesel]

[quote=jakez4ut;490084]i wouldn't call him overrated...3 rings=rated just about right. quote]

I don't think Brady isnt overrated. I big games(Super Bowls) hes been almost perfect......I hate it but its true.

[kptvol]

I feel like if he were as good as everyone is saying the Pats should be doing better. They have two awesome running backs and a great defense. I've seen him completely blow it for his team before, so the idea that he doesn't have meltdowns is absurd. Every QB screws up sometimes. He's not unflappable. That said, he's still one of the best QB's in the NFL.

[jakez4ut]

Originally Posted by kptvol

I feel like if he were as good as everyone is saying the Pats should be doing better. They have two awesome running backs and a great defense. I've seen him completely blow it for his team before, so the idea that he doesn't have meltdowns is absurd. Every QB screws up sometimes. He's not unflappable. That said, he's still one of the best QB's in the NFL.

they're leading their division.......

they've lost two of their best WR's........

i think he's doing fine. this year was the first year since 01 or something that they've lost back to back games...

but i agree, he's not unflappable....but more times than not, he's clutch. and i hate him for it.