It's still a pretty ham-fisted approach.
Don't get me wrong, I dislike what the media have become. Not gonna defend their perspective for one stinkin' minute.
But the primary reason you keep the media away from practices is so that you don't give away your playbook. You can do that without closing off the entire fall camp.
As one example: watch Fingers' compilation of all the coverage of our fall camp over the next several weeks. See how many 11-on-11 drills you get to see. How many plays you see run. Hint: it's gonna be awfully close to the number zero.
That's not because they're not going 11-on-11. They're doing plenty of it. But those parts of the practices are media-blocked. What the media get to see are the individual and, at most, unit-on-unit drills.
Voila, no playbook reveals.
Orgeron shutting everything down is just laziness, unwillingness to get one of his staff to take a few minutes to figure out what parts should be open and what parts shouldn't.
More power to him if that's what he wants to do, but it's still a ham-fisted approach.