Saban or Spurrier or Meyer?

[BigPapaVol]

Originally Posted by catfish

whoa, easy on the logic there. they don't take kindly to that on these boards.
they prefer talking smack about the future and getting behind their cry-baby coach... so look out!! they're coming! mark it down! LOL

Laugh out loud? That makes me feel sorry for you.
Posted via VolNation Mobile

[VolDad]

Saban

[tvolsfan]

Originally Posted by Vols N Shocks

Meyer's success is with Dan Mullen.

I'd say losing Harvin had as much of an impact as losing Mullen.

[Mr. Two Bits]

Originally Posted by catfish

whoa, easy on the logic there. they don't take kindly to that on these boards.
they prefer talking smack about the future and getting behind their cry-baby coach... so look out!! they're coming! mark it down! LOL

I beg of you... No Lol.

[TXA&M07]

Excluding recruiting, I rank them;

Saban
The Visor
Urban

[thebjd]

Originally Posted by Mr. Two Bits

I beg of you... No Lol.

No Lol and I think Spurrier is the best of the three. Look at Duke and Florida. Those were big turn-arounds. Look at USCjr and the teams they have beaten. I realize USCjr may just be the final destinations for coaches past their prime but Spurrier has made them respectable.

[tvolsfan]

Originally Posted by thebjd

No Lol and I think Spurrier is the best of the three. Look at Duke and Florida. Those were big turn-arounds. Look at USCjr and the teams they have beaten. I realize USCjr may just be the final destinations for coaches past their prime but Spurrier has made them respectable.

Lou Holtz made them respectable. Spurrier made them arrogant.

[Mr. Two Bits]

I think Spurrier has done as much as anyone could have with South Carolina' s program.

[tvolsfan]

He really didn't do much more than Lou Holtz. Holtz had less to work with.

[VictoryVille101]

Originally Posted by tvolsfan

I'd say losing Harvin had as much of an impact as losing Mullen.

Yeah, a 7-0 impact. All kidding aside, I think now we can all look back as fans and realize how special Percy was and hopefully continue to be in the league.

[tvolsfan]

So who do you think was a bigger loss?

[Brian McCat]

Originally Posted by Mr. Two Bits

I think Spurrier has done as much as anyone could have with South Carolina' s program.

You really think so? I don't agree at all.

[milohimself]

Originally Posted by utgibbs

As far as effectiveness at the college level (where recruiting is 9/10ths of the law), obviously Saban and Meyer are ahead.

However, I just wonder if the OBC isn't still a better Xs and Os guy. I might be showing my age here, but I just think if anyone can find a way to exploit a weakness in a defense it's SOS.

If the OBC recruited as much as he golfed, USCe might be a contenda'.....

Sort of in the same boat. There's room for improvement, but his tenure so far at USCjr. has shown to me that he is at least a decent coach and more than a product of the system he brought to Florida in the 90's. They get a string of three or four top notch recruiting classes, then you've got a team in the discussion for the SEC title.

Ultimately, though, it's South Carolina and that won't happen.